default_background
✕

Find the best tutors and institutes for Class 11 Tuition

Find Best Class 11 Tuition

Please select a Category.

Please select a Locality.

No matching category found.

No matching Locality found.

Q2.4(f):
Explain this statement clearly : “To call a dimensional quantity ‘large’ or ‘small’ is meaningless without specifying a standard for comparison”. In view of this, reframe the following statements wherever necessary : (f) the speed of sound is much smaller than the speed of light.

Solution :

Theoretical Foundation: The Concept of Relativity in Measurement

In the field of metrology, a measurement is defined as the comparison of an unknown quantity with a known standard unit. The adjectives "large" or "small" are relative, not absolute, because physical quantities possess dimensions that exist on a continuum. Without a reference point (a standard), magnitude lacks context. Mathematically, if $Q$ is the magnitude of a physical quantity, the statement $Q > Q_{ref}$ or $Q < Q_{ref}$ requires the definition of $Q_{ref}$ to be scientifically valid. [Per the Principle of Dimensional Homogeneity and Relative Comparison].

Step 1: Analyzing the Original Statement

Original Statement: "The speed of sound is much smaller than the speed of light."

While this statement is qualitatively correct in the context of vacuum propagation, it technically lacks the mention of the standard of comparison. The standard here is the speed of light in vacuum ($c \approx 3 \times 10^8 \text{ m/s}$). By comparing the speed of sound ($v_s \approx 343 \text{ m/s}$ at $20^\circ\text{C}$) to $c$, we arrive at the quantitative disparity.

Step 2: Graphical Representation of Magnitude Scales

0 Speed of Sound Speed of Light Scale: $10^2$ to $10^8$ m/s

Step 3: Reframing the Statement

To satisfy the requirement of specifying a standard for comparison, we must explicitly link the speed of sound to the universal constant $c$.

Context Reframed Statement
Precise Formulation "The speed of sound in air is approximately $1.14 \times 10^{-6}$ times the speed of light in a vacuum."

Step 4: Justification

  • Mathematical Rigor: By defining the ratio $R = \frac{v_{sound}}{c} \approx \frac{343}{3 \times 10^8} \approx 1.14 \times 10^{-6}$, we remove the ambiguity of the term "smaller."
  • Logical Deduction: The statement is no longer a vague subjective observation but a quantitative comparison against a universal physical constant [Per the requirements of SI unit standardization].

Final Solution: The statement should be reframed as: "The speed of sound in air is approximately $10^{-6}$ times the speed of light in vacuum," as this provides the necessary standard of comparison to render the term 'smaller' scientifically meaningful.


More Questions from Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements EXERCISES


CBSE Solutions for Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements


Chapters in CBSE - Class 11 Physics


Top Tutors who teach Units and Measurements

(7)
Top Tutor
locationImg Hari Nagar, Delhi
experience 5 yrs of Exp students 6 students
greenClock 496 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 400 per hour
CBSE and IGCSE Economics Teacher
Online Classes Online Classes

My teaching is strictly aligned with the learning objectives which a student needs to acquire over a period of time.It involves presentation of the content in an interesting way, helping the student to process it and testing him for the same.

Ada

She is very understanding and teaches statistics very well, Super sweet and very very kind teacher. Had a beautiful experience with her as a student.

Skills: Economics
Also teaches: Class 12 Tuition, Class 9 Tuition and more

(64)
superTutorSuper Tutor
locationImg Patpar Ganj, Delhi
experience 20 yrs of Exp students 10 students
greenClock 971 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 500 per hour
I have vast experience in teaching accounts,costing, management accounting and financial management.
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home

I am a teacher. I love teaching and want to share my knowledge with my students. I will take online classes. My approach combines clear concepts, regular practice, and student-friendly strategies to make learning effective and enjoyable.

Janvi

My tutor is very thorough and took careful measures in helping me grasp a concept that I had forgotten." "he made me really think about how I would come up with the answer." "I liked how he is straight forward and to the point." "Great tutor that helped me so much!"

Skills: Accounts , Accountancy
Also teaches: CA Coaching, MBA Tuition and more

(52)
Top Tutor
locationImg Karampura, Delhi
experience 10 yrs of Exp
greenClock 5 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 2500 per hour
Tutor
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home

I teach and help students to achieve immediate and long term goals. My experience as a personal tutor and the founder of an online educational startup 'MinDely' has helped him gain knowledge of child psychology and understanding students needs and takes measures accordingly. I plan the lessons as per the students ability to cope up and moreover upon their needs. My teaching technique is student friendly and easy to understand which helps students understand it better. Weekly test conducted by him helps the parents to know the students performance.

Jenissha

Sir explains concepts clearly and makes an effort to make sure that i understand the logic behind formulas rather than just memorising them.The examples discussed in class are helpful,which makes the subject easier to understand. He is patient with doubts which creates a positive learning environment. Since this subject is relatively new and has no official NCERT textbook his self prepared material helps alot.

Skills: Mathematics , Physics
Also teaches: Class 9 Tuition, Class 10 Tuition and more

(15)
Top Tutor
locationImg Ashok Nagar Block 14, Delhi
experience 17 yrs of Exp students 7 students
greenClock 30 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 800 per hour
Teacher
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home
regularClasses Tutor's home

I am teacher with experience of 17 years. Provides notes and assignments.

Taharah

Took online classes from Deepti maam . She is knowledgeable and professional teacher. Took regular test. Highly recommended to take online class as there is no difference in online and student home . Lectures taken from her.

Skills: Economics , Accounts and more
Also teaches: Class 12 Tuition

locationImg Sector 34, Noida
experience 5 yrs of Exp
rsIcon 300 per hour
5 years Classroom teaching and 2 years online teaching experience.
Online Classes Online Classes

I have 2 years of classroom teaching experience as a PostGraduate Teacher. I was been teaching Business Studies and Economics.

Also teaches: Class 8 Tuition, French Language and more

Other Subjects in CBSE - Class 11

Worksheet Icon

Download free CBSE - Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements EXERCISES worksheets

Download Now

Find Best Class 11 Tuition ?

Find Now »