default_background
✕

Find the best tutors and institutes for Class 11 Tuition

Find Best Class 11 Tuition

Please select a Category.

Please select a Locality.

No matching category found.

No matching Locality found.

Q2.4(e):
Explain this statement clearly : “To call a dimensional quantity ‘large’ or ‘small’ is meaningless without specifying a standard for comparison”. In view of this, reframe the following statements wherever necessary : (e) a proton is much more massive than an electron

Solution :

Theoretical Foundation: The Relativity of Magnitude

The statement “To call a dimensional quantity ‘large’ or ‘small’ is meaningless without specifying a standard for comparison” is rooted in the Theory of Dimensions. In physical sciences, a dimensioned quantity $Q$ is expressed as $Q = n \cdot u$, where $n$ is the numerical value and $u$ is the unit or standard. A "large" or "small" value is essentially a comparison of the ratio $n_1/n_2$ relative to a reference scale. Without a common denominator or unit standard, magnitude remains subjective and mathematically indeterminate [Per the Principles of Dimensional Analysis].

Step 1: Analyzing the Original Statement

The statement "a proton is much more massive than an electron" is linguistically descriptive but physically imprecise. It identifies the entities (proton, electron) and the property (mass), but fails to define the "scale of largeness." To achieve scientific rigor, we must quantify the ratio of their masses relative to a standard unit (e.g., the electron mass).

Step 2: Empirical Data Gathering

Utilizing established physical constants [Per CODATA 2018 recommendations]:

  • Mass of a proton ($m_p$): $\approx 1.6726 \times 10^{-27} \, \text{kg}$
  • Mass of an electron ($m_e$): $\approx 9.1093 \times 10^{-31} \, \text{kg}$

Step 3: Calculating the Comparison Standard

To quantify "much more massive," we calculate the ratio $R = \frac{m_p}{m_e}$:

$R = \frac{1.6726 \times 10^{-27} \, \text{kg}}{9.1093 \times 10^{-31} \, \text{kg}} \approx 1836$

[By Arithmetic Division of Scalar Quantities]

Visual Representation of Relative Mass

Electron ($m_e$) Proton ($\approx 1836 m_e$) Scale Comparison: Proton is 1836 times the mass of an electron

Step 4: Reframing the Statement

To remove the ambiguity of the word "much," we replace it with the specific ratio derived from our standard comparison.

Reframed Statement: "The mass of a proton is approximately 1836 times greater than the mass of an electron."

Final Solution: The original statement is refined to: "The mass of a proton is approximately 1836 times that of an electron," as the term "much" is a relative qualitative descriptor that lacks the precision required for physical laws; the ratio $m_p/m_e \approx 1836$ provides the necessary, objective standard for comparison.


More Questions from Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements EXERCISES


CBSE Solutions for Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements


Chapters in CBSE - Class 11 Physics


Top Tutors who teach Units and Measurements

Manish Kukreja Class 11 Tuition trainer in Jaipur
(68)
Top Tutor
locationImg Vaishali Nagar, Jaipur
experience 9 yrs of Exp students 9 students
greenClock 3087 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 600 per hour
10 Years Teaching, 7 Years Industry: Your Expert in Accountancy, Finance and Taxation!
Online Classes Online Classes

As a certified and top-ranked tutor on UrbanPro with over 9 years of teaching experience, I specialize in guiding Class 11 students as they transition into the commerce stream. My strength lies in simplifying complex Accountancy concepts and building a strong foundational understanding. Backed by 7+ years of industry experience in Accounting, Auditing, and Taxation, I effectively bridge theoretical learning with real-world application. My goal is to make learning engaging, practical, and confidence-boosting, helping students not only excel in exams but also prepare for higher studies in commerce.

Sam Park

He is good teacher for study. He teach detailly about subject. His teach style is strict. But sometimes this style is good for students.

Skills: Accounts , Accounting and more
Also teaches: MBA Tuition, Class 10 Tuition and more

(11)
Top Tutor
locationImg Peera Garhi, Delhi
experience 8 yrs of Exp students 2 students
greenClock 72 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 700 per hour
Experience &Certified Computer Science/IP instructor
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home
regularClasses Tutor's home

I am having more than 8+ years of experience to teach the Computer Science/ informatic Practice subject to the students of 11th class. I can teach all boards students.

Skills: Computer Science

(15)
Top Tutor
locationImg Dilshad Garden, Delhi
experience 4 yrs of Exp students 3 students
greenClock 969 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 260 per hour
Commerce educator with CA degree
Online Classes Online Classes

I am a Chartered Accountant by profession and have been teaching Commerce subjects—primarily Accounting and Economics—for the past 4 years. I work with BCom/BSc students and CA aspirants, helping them build strong conceptual clarity and practical understanding. Teaching is my passion and hobby, and I focus on delivering quality education by maintaining small group sizes (2–3 students at a time). This allows me to give individual attention, ensuring that every student understands the concepts thoroughly and gains confidence. My teaching approach is practical-based, designed to bridge the gap between academic theories and real-world industry applications. I emphasize how concepts are applied in actual business environments—both in private and public sectors—so students can connect textbook knowledge to real scenarios. I prefer conducting online, individual sessions to provide personalized support and address each student’s learning style and pace. I teach using a whiteboard for clear and visual explanations. For CA students, I recommend specific books aligned with the syllabus. For Class 11 and 12, I rely on their existing school books but provide additional notes or references on request to avoid overloading them. While I haven't pursued awards in teaching, the positive feedback from my students and their academic success bring me immense satisfaction. My goal is to make learning effective, relevant, and engaging for every student I teach.

Skills: Economics , Accounts and more
Also teaches: Class 10 Tuition, CA Coaching and more

(28)
Top Tutor
locationImg Chembur West, Mumbai
experience 17 yrs of Exp students 9 students
greenClock 273 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 750 per hour
An Experienced chemistry partner of you of your journey of 11 and 12
Online Classes Online Classes
regularClasses Tutor's home

I am a teacher. I provide online and tutor home tuitions. I am M.Sc.(organic chemistry) B.Ed. I have an experience of teaching chemistry in Engineering college , schools (Aditya Birla Public School, Sagar public School),in coaching classes., home tuitions and online tuitions. I have around 15 years teaching experience.

Chhavi

My daughter took demo class on physics from Sheeba ma'am. She explained the topic in detail and helped in resolving the doubts. Overall a helpful session.

Skills: Chemistry
Also teaches: Class 12 Tuition

(109)
Top Tutor
locationImg Hiran Magri Sector 14, Udaipur
experience 7 yrs of Exp students 73 students
greenClock 3805 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 400 per hour
"Education is the key to unlocking your future"
Online Classes Online Classes

I am a home tutor I teach since 2016. my teaching style is easy and impactful I use examples and mostly I use the questioner method mostly I used linear questions for learning. and I teach you how to prepare a short note in an effective way and how to convert your short not learning into easy type answers and i promise you as a tutor the whole procdure you will enjoy.

Bhai No

I’m really thankful to my TTN accounts teacher for the way they teach. Accounts can feel confusing at times, but the way every topic is explained so clearly makes it much easier to understand. They always start from the basics and make sure everyone is on the same page before moving ahead. Doubts are never ignored, and the examples given in class actually help things make sense. Because of their teaching, my confidence in accounts has improved a lot. It honestly feels easier and less stressful to study the subject now.

Skills: Economics , Accountancy and more
Also teaches: Class 12 Tuition, BA Tuition

Other Subjects in CBSE - Class 11

Worksheet Icon

Download free CBSE - Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements EXERCISES worksheets

Download Now

Find Best Class 11 Tuition ?

Find Now »