default_background
✕

Find the best tutors and institutes for Class 11 Tuition

Find Best Class 11 Tuition

Please select a Category.

Please select a Locality.

No matching category found.

No matching Locality found.

Q2.4(e):
Explain this statement clearly : “To call a dimensional quantity ‘large’ or ‘small’ is meaningless without specifying a standard for comparison”. In view of this, reframe the following statements wherever necessary : a proton is much more massive than an electron

Solution :

1. Theoretical Foundation of Dimensional Comparison

The statement highlights that quantities with dimensions (such as mass, length, or time) are inherently relative. In physics, a numerical value for a physical quantity $Q$ is expressed as $Q = n \cdot u$, where $n$ is the numerical magnitude and $u$ is the unit [Per the International System of Units (SI) framework]. To classify a quantity as "large" or "small" without a reference scale is logically incomplete because magnitude is defined by the ratio between the observed quantity and a standard reference quantity.

Electron ($m_e$) Proton ($m_p$) Comparison Standard: Mass of Electron ($m_e$)

2. Analysis of the Specific Statement

Original Statement: "A proton is much more massive than an electron."

Critique: While the statement provides a qualitative comparison, it lacks precision. To validate the term "much more," we must employ a dimensionless ratio—the ratio of the masses of the two particles [By definition of dimensionless ratios in dimensional analysis].

3. Quantitative Derivation

  • Mass of Proton ($m_p$) $\approx 1.67 \times 10^{-27} \text{ kg}$
  • Mass of Electron ($m_e$) $\approx 9.11 \times 10^{-31} \text{ kg}$
  • Calculating the ratio: $\frac{m_p}{m_e} = \frac{1.67 \times 10^{-27}}{9.11 \times 10^{-31}} \approx 1836$

4. Reframed Statement

To adhere to the requirement of specifying a standard for comparison, the statement is reformulated as follows:

Reframed Statement: "The mass of a proton is approximately 1836 times larger than the mass of an electron."

Comparison Aspect Methodology
Standard Reference Mass of the electron ($m_e$)
Dimensional Status Dimensionless (Mass/Mass = $[M^0 L^0 T^0]$)
Logical Clarity Quantified by the factor of 1836

Final Solution: The statement "a proton is much more massive than an electron" is rendered precise by stating: "The mass of a proton is approximately 1836 times the mass of an electron," as this defines the electron's mass as the standard of comparison and provides a clear quantitative ratio.


More Questions from Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements EXERCISES


CBSE Solutions for Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements


Chapters in CBSE - Class 11 Physics


Top Tutors who teach Units and Measurements

(6)
Top Tutor
locationImg Bajaj Nagar, Nagpur
experience 3 yrs of Exp
Tutor
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home

Only the students attitude makes a subject HARD or EASY. FUNDAMENTALS are the only need for all Competitive Exams. Once you GET it, cant be bothered again.

Skills: English , Mathematics and more
Also teaches: Class 9 Tuition, Class 12 Tuition and more

(13)
Top Tutor
locationImg Ramachandra Puram, Hyderabad
experience 10 yrs of Exp students 4 students
greenClock 252 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 400 per hour
Accountancy for Class 11 & 12 | Strong Basics | Smart Practice | Better Scores
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home

I am an experienced academic teacher and tutor, specialised in teaching Accountancy to Class 11 students. My teaching approach focuses on building strong fundamentals, simplifying complex chapters and explaining practical problems step by step and making learning engaging and effective. Through interactive teaching, personalised attention and exam-oriented practice, I help students prepare effectively and perform well in their exams.

Nakshatra reddy

He teaches really well so that we can understand the concept.His concept understanding is very good.

Skills: Accountancy , Accounting and more
Also teaches: Class 12 Tuition, CA Coaching

(4)
Top Tutor
locationImg Durlavganj, Chandrakona Road
experience 12 yrs of Exp students 6 students
greenClock 262 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 500 per hour
Post graduate teacher with 10 years teaching experience
Online Classes Online Classes

Krishnendu Gorai – Expert Physics Tutor for Class 12, JEE, and NEET. About Me: I am Krishnendu Gorai, a dedicated and experienced Physics educator with over 10 years of teaching experience in CBSE and competitive exam preparation. I specialize in teaching Class 11 and 12 Physics, along with focused coaching for JEE (Main and Advanced) and NEET aspirants. My goal is to make Physics simple, logical, and scoring for every student. I believe that with the right guidance, any student can master Physics and perform excellently in both board exams and competitive exams. Subjects and Courses Offered: Class 12 Physics (CBSE and State Boards): - Electrostatics - Current Electricity - Magnetic Effects of Current - Electromagnetic Induction - Alternating Current - Ray and Wave Optics - Modern Physics - Semiconductor Electronics JEE (Main and Advanced) Physics: - Concept-based preparation - Advanced numerical problem solving - Previous year questions and mock tests - Strategy for high-rank performance NEET Physics Preparation: - NCERT-focused theory - Important formulas and shortcuts - Assertion-reason and MCQ practice - Full syllabus revision and test series.

Siddhartha Pal

The classes are progressing well; however, there is an urgent need to begin conducting regular assessments, which have not yet been implemented.

Skills: Physics
Also teaches: Class 10 Tuition, Class 9 Tuition and more

(34)
Top Tutor
locationImg Garia Baishnabghata Patuli Township, Kolkata
experience 11 yrs of Exp students 5 students
greenClock 1286 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 400 per hour
I have a degree in Mechanical Engineering I have conducted over 12000 online sessions on Math. durin
Online Classes Online Classes
homeTutions Student's Home

I am a retired Mechanical Engineer. I have over 11 years of experience as online tutor(Math.)I am able to tutor all boards. I am fully conversant with Algebra, Geometry, Trigonometry, Calculus , Descriptive statistics.I have taken over 12000 math. sessions and fully confident to tutor students up to Class 12.i teach with skype, Bitpaper white board, advanced scientific calculator and different graph programs.

Skills: Mathematics
Also teaches: Class 8 Tuition, Class 9 Tuition and more

(51)
Top Tutor
locationImg SCB Nagar, Kothagudem
experience 20 yrs of Exp students 2 students
greenClock 2893 hrs of classes completed
rsIcon 500 per hour
Mathematics Facilitator 22 Years experience
Online Classes Online Classes

5 years of experience in Kiit International school for 12 standard CBSE CLASSES and 4 years of experience in NARAYANA e Techno in Rayachoti Kadapa.which is equal to +1 syllabus

Skills: Mathematics
Also teaches: Math Olympiad, Class 7 Tuition and more

Other Subjects in CBSE - Class 11

Worksheet Icon

Download free CBSE - Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements EXERCISES worksheets

Download Now

Find Best Class 11 Tuition ?

Find Now »