Is there a difference between Shall I come in and May I come in?

Asked by Last Modified  

62 Answers

Follow 3
Answer

Please enter your answer

Shall I - Asking what to do May I - Asking for permission or future possibility
Comments

Trainer

One big difference is that may is more formal second difference is shall has probability Wether the doer is asking to go in or not... where as may has courtesy to ask the person to whom your are addressing.
Comments

English Language Tutor, GRE Verbal and Writing Tutor

Yes. The former is less polite than the latter. "Shall" indicates a strong assertion while "may" asks for permission and indicates possibility.
Comments

.Net and WPF coaching with interview cracks and mock interviews

There is a very subtle difference. You will ask "May I come in?" when you want to go in and are asking for permission and say "Shall I come in?" when you don't really want to go but will go in if someone says "Yes please come in." The latter is used like, if your dad is reading his paper on the couch...
read more
There is a very subtle difference. You will ask "May I come in?" when you want to go in and are asking for permission and say "Shall I come in?" when you don't really want to go but will go in if someone says "Yes please come in." The latter is used like, if your dad is reading his paper on the couch and he hears a big crash in the kitchen and is concerned your mom must have fallen but its a big inconvenience to actually get up and go and see, so he will shout from the couch, "What was that? Are you ok dear? Shall I come and help you?." If your mom says yes then he goes in else he doesn't bother. read less
Comments

teacher with passion

Yes of course...shall and may are two modal auxiliary verbs.shall is mainly used expressive of offers, , suggestions and requests. May is used to ask for permission.
Comments

Yes Ganeshan. There is a difference between these two. When you ask someone ''Shall I come in?'', it sounds like you are ordering someone to let you in. However, when you say ''May I come in?'', it is more polite and sounds like you are requesting a person to allow you to come in. That's the only difference...
read more
Yes Ganeshan. There is a difference between these two. When you ask someone ''Shall I come in?'', it sounds like you are ordering someone to let you in. However, when you say ''May I come in?'', it is more polite and sounds like you are requesting a person to allow you to come in. That's the only difference between these two. When you ask someone's permission to allow you to do something, you should be polite in your language because you want his/her permission.So, you are requesting that person politely by asking him ''May I come in?''. ''Shall'' is a bit harsh, so it doesn't go well with asking permission to do something. Now, I hope I have cleared your doubt Ganeshan. read less
Comments

Tutor

yes may i come in is a polite way of getting permition.where as shaii i come in shows that u r just want to enter with out any care
Comments

Certified IELTS Tutor with 15 yrs of teaching experience.

Shall and may are both modal auxiliary verbs. However ; Shall is used when making suggestions, offers or requests. Whereas ; may is used mainly when asking or granting permission
Comments

Financial Accounting Expert

Shall I come in, conveys a simple question asking whether he will come in at a future point of time. Think in terms of an actor seeking directions in a play, that whether he will enter or not. The word 'may' in the question conveys the act of seeking permission at that instance only.
Comments

Improver

Shall i come in means if there is your requirement or not in the room. May i come in means you yourself want to go in and just want to get in
Comments

View 60 more Answers

Related Questions

What does "for your information" mean in spoken English?
"For your Information" or "FYI" is a statement used to draw attention and provide more fact or detail about something or the topic of Conversation. Say for example, Tom and Shailie are talking about dance...
Profile Photo
Saranya
0 0
View Comments6
I have filled as per your tool but did not get any response.
You have to contact the students by using your coins then you will get response.
Profile Photo
Thimmappa
What is the best spoken English institute in Hyderabad?
At Miyapur - where I take classes
Profile Photo
Kiran
0 0
View Comments6
What should I do to learn spoken English without any coaching classes?
You can watch English movies with subtitles at first to get the hang of the language then later start watching them without the subtitles. This will help you to pick up new vocabulary, the pronunciation...
Profile Photo
Suri
0 0
View Comments5

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons

VOCABULARY for ielts preparation
Word of the Day Cadre pronunciation : kædri Hindi: काड्र / कैड्री noun ढांचा, सं-वर्ग(m), कंकाल, कैडर(m), काडर, ठाट, अंजर पंजर a nucleus of military personnel capable of expansiona small unit...
Profile Photo

Past Modal Practice Exercise
Make the correct past modal form (use could have / would have / should have + past participle). 1) I (buy) bread but I didn’t know we needed it. (past possibility). 2) We (invite) so many people...
Profile Photo

Spoken English Basics - Animal sounds
Animal Cry/Sounds Ape→→ →→→ →→Gibber Asses→→ →→→ →→Bray Bears→→ →→→ →→Growl Bees→→...
Profile Photo

How to speak fluent English
Five golden rules for spoken English:- 1) learn whole phrases, not individual words. 2)learn in chunks #Grammatical pattern #Discourse fillers #Idioms,phrasal verb ,collocation 3)learn by ears-...
Profile Photo

Word of the Day for IELTS & ENGLISH
Word of the Day Entourage noun परिजन(m)वातावरणघेरापरिकरअनुगामी(m)प्रतिवेशमुहासिरापरिचारक गणपरिचारकगण nounthe group following and attending to some important personSynonymscortege, retinue, suite अनुचर...
Profile Photo

Recommended Articles

If you think English is enough to communicate with anybody in this world, you are sadly misinformed. Statistically the highest spoken foreign language in the world is Chinese with 20.7%, followed by English at 6.2%. That means that 93.8% of people do not speak English. This makes it necessary to learn another foreign language...

Read full article >

When globalization was out of picture, it was enough to know just the mother tongue. Since globalization and out-sourcing have become part of life, there is a nagging need to learn new languages. Foreign languages help us to communicate with potential clients, sell our ideas and bond with their culture. It could be opening...

Read full article >

Learning any second language could be a little bit tricky. However, to learn a language, one needs to write, read, understand and speak it appropriately. Therefore, many students and professionals find it helpful in learning a foreign language from a reputable and reliable source. A second language helps them to increase...

Read full article >

Due to globalization of the Indian economy, the demand for learning foreign languages is on the rise. ITES (Information Technology Enabled Service) and Outsourcing have brought a lot of job opportunities paving the way for the learning foreign languages. German is the native language of more than 100 million people in...

Read full article >

Looking for Spoken English classes?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you