What is the difference's between lndian classical songs and western classical songs

Asked by Last Modified  

10 Answers

Follow 1
Answer

Please enter your answer

Sikha Datta

Tutor

Indian classical music has roots in spirituality. Ragas have specific times of day or seasons associated with them. Western classical music has no such them. Harmony and melody are important in western classical music.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Jazz Pianist, Composer & Educator

Taking about classical music, I believe one of the major difference between indian and western classical lies in the harmony. Indian classical music makes use of rhythm and melody only. You must have noticed that indian classical musicians play along with tanpura or harmonium but there are no chord progressions,...
read more
Taking about classical music, I believe one of the major difference between indian and western classical lies in the harmony. Indian classical music makes use of rhythm and melody only. You must have noticed that indian classical musicians play along with tanpura or harmonium but there are no chord progressions, whereas in western classical music, you get to learn the melody, rhythm and the harmony. Although, when you consider indian fusion, then you can get to listen to harmony too. For ex: Listen to the band "Shakti" which consisted of legends like Zakir Hussain, John McLaughlin, Ramnad Raghavan, etc. Later, the group started touring with Shankar Mahadevan. Now you aren't just limited to just 1 raga or scale. This video starts with an alaap by Shankar Mahadevan along interesting chord changes by John McLaughlin. Also, I don't agree with the above written answer by Ms. Subbulakshmi. She is trying to compare indian classical and western music (rock, pop, etc instead of classical). If you think that way, lets take indian music aka Bollywood (non classical), don't you get beats predominantly and awful lyrics with poor arranging and composing? And don't forget you have opera in western classical music, which also makes use of emotional lyrics. Musicality is a very subjective topic. There are tons of genres all over the world. You don't generalize them. I hope this helped you :) read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

I am a post graduate in Indian classical . I am a JRF NET holder. I also completed VISHARAD ( 6 YRS ) from GANDHI SANGEET MAHAVIDYALAYA.

Hi indrani .. First of all would like to tell you tht there is nothing classical in western music . Offcource their music is containing seven swara as Indian but it does meek it classical as Indian my dear .. Indian music is melodious nd western music is harmonic .. Nd melody brings lot off creativity...
read more
Hi indrani .. First of all would like to tell you tht there is nothing classical in western music . Offcource their music is containing seven swara as Indian but it does meek it classical as Indian my dear .. Indian music is melodious nd western music is harmonic .. Nd melody brings lot off creativity feelings in singing whether western is all about range nd feelings not alap taan kab khataka murki meed nd much more .. Hope you understood .. If any thing else you can ask me dear .. Listen Samarjeet Randhawa on you tube.. Stay bless read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Vocal Music Calsses

Western classical music is harmony chord base Hindustani Classical/Indian Classical are on shruti base
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Music Teacher

Hi Indrani ! Basically, Indian Classical Music first derives from emotional lyrics tuned to several swaras and raghas to suit the respective emotions.To be precise, Indian classical music is based on emotional lyrics. But the western Music is basically on rhythm and beats predominantly rather than the...
read more
Hi Indrani ! Basically, Indian Classical Music first derives from emotional lyrics tuned to several swaras and raghas to suit the respective emotions.To be precise, Indian classical music is based on emotional lyrics. But the western Music is basically on rhythm and beats predominantly rather than the lyrics ! read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Carnatic Vocal Music with 10 year of experienced and certified Vocal instructor

I think at least 5year
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Guitar, Tabla, Keyboard, Violin, Flute, Piano, Vocals, mandolin

Very basic and first difference is Indian classical Music is based on Medoly means one note at a time and westeren classical music is based on harmony means more than one notes are connected and related to each other, it is known as chord. Still there are so many aspects which differs both music...
read more
Very basic and first difference is Indian classical Music is based on Medoly means one note at a time and westeren classical music is based on harmony means more than one notes are connected and related to each other, it is known as chord. Still there are so many aspects which differs both music but you will understand well if u start learning. Have a nice time regards - Jignesh sir ( Versatile music academy) read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Music Teacher

Lots of difference.. A professional can guide you...
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Having more than 15 years experience of Knowledge Sharing

Indian melody , western harmony :) rest all is quite difficult to elaborate here. Listen some tracks of both types and you will feel the difference.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Carnatic (Vocal & Violin) Expert

Western music is based on harmony, and Indian classical music is based on melody. This is the basic difference.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

View 8 more Answers

Related Questions

What makes a person to be a great musician?
Dedication and interest. If you don't have either, even if you work out it won't work. Music is a feeling which won't blossom if it's not felt :)
Syed
0 0
5
Is Carnatic music and Karnataka related?
Yes, Carnatic music and Karnataka are historically and culturally related, though the term "Carnatic" itself is broader. The name "Carnatic" is believed to have originated from the word "Karnāṭaka," which...
Swarnalakshmi
0 0
5
How to learn music?
Join a good place. start off with the type of music that interests you. Keep building after that.
Karuna
If I want to learn keyboard what model of Yamaha keyboard should I buy?
Many Beginner versions of PSR models are available. You can buy it online too.
Samir
I need keyboard teachers who are teaching Carnatic on keyboard to conduct workshops in their respective areas.
I think people who have the knowledge of playing keyboard will be accustomed to western music notations etc. So I guess you need to approach a music school/institution/individual who teaches keyboard with Indian notation
Sridevi R.

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons

Learn to sing a Vocal Lick and take this challenge!
Take this challenge.Follow the lick series, cover or improvise.Watch the videos to see which one suits you.There is room for beginners and intermediate musicians.Record your self and upload the video...

Trill Route School Of Contemporary Music

0 0
0
Strumming Patterns 2 | Beginner Guitar Lesson in Hindi

Gourav Singh

1 0
0
How to eliminate Stage Fear?
Stage fear can be eliminated by 3 main aspects, that is:- 1.Your music knowledge,2.Your voice and3.Your right singing posture(sitting or standing).Be thorough in your musical study and gain the knowledge...

Vinod

0 0
0
Learn to sing in Abheri Raga
Course: Learn to sing in Abheri Raga Module1:Understand and learn the Raga Abheri Module2:Sing songs based on Abheri M1: 1.Understand the Arohanam and Avarohanam of Abheri Ragam (DNA) 2.Learn to...

Vinod

0 0
0
fingure scales
A Major scale 1. A B C# D E F# G# A 5/0 5/2 5/4 4/0 4/2 4/4 3/1 3/2 0 2 4 0 2 4 1 2 2. 3/2 3/4 2/2 2/3 2/5 1/2 1/4 1/5 1 3 1 2 4 1 3 4
V

Vinit K.

0 0
0

Recommended Articles

Importance of professional training for learning...

Why you need professional guidance? Acquire an accurate map i.e. professional training. An accurate map helps you reach the top faster! Imagine you are taking a trip to an important destination inside an unfamiliar city without an accurate map? Now imagine the city is filled with hundreds of thousands of other people,...

Read full article >

5 Musical Instruments for Children to Learn Now

Children dream of being rock stars when they grow up. It is seen that brain development, learning and improvement of social skills depend a lot on playing musical instruments. So parents hoping their child to become the next Mozart or Bach need to let them cultivate their creativity. However, as there is a whole range...

Read full article >

5 Ways Music Benefits Children

Music is an entertainment source for everyone but for some, it is the greatest form of art. Music is wings to the mind and flight to the creativity as it builds up self-confidence, enhances mood and sprinkles creativity to a child. In fact, musical experiences in childhood can speed up brain development, learning language...

Read full article >

Improve English pronunciation -- tips and tricks

Let us be honest with ourselves. Reading about pronunciation is not going to take you anywhere. You have to speak English to master the pronunciations and it doesn’t matter if you go wrong. You fall down, you learn to get up. It is no different with English. Every English speaking country has its own form of English....

Read full article >

Find Music Classes near you
Music Classes in Bangalore
Music Classes in Delhi
Music Classes in Mumbai
Music Classes in Chennai
Music Classes in Kolkata
Music Classes in Hyderabad
Music Classes in Pune
Music Classes in Noida
Music Classes in Gurgaon
Music Classes in Lucknow
Online Music Classes

Looking for Music Classes?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you