UrbanPro

Take Class 11 Tuition from the Best Tutors

  • Affordable fees
  • 1-1 or Group class
  • Flexible Timings
  • Verified Tutors

Write the drawbacks in Mendeleev’s periodic table that led to its modification.

Asked by Last Modified  

Follow 1
Answer

Please enter your answer

Mendeleev's periodic table, while groundbreaking and influential in the development of modern chemistry, had several drawbacks that eventually led to its modification and the development of the modern periodic table. Some of the key drawbacks include: Use of Atomic Mass as the Organizing Principle:...
read more

Mendeleev's periodic table, while groundbreaking and influential in the development of modern chemistry, had several drawbacks that eventually led to its modification and the development of the modern periodic table. Some of the key drawbacks include:

  1. Use of Atomic Mass as the Organizing Principle: Mendeleev organized elements primarily by increasing atomic mass. While this arrangement generally worked well and allowed him to predict the properties of unknown elements, it led to inconsistencies and anomalies, such as the inversion of the order of certain elements to maintain similar chemical properties. Additionally, the discovery of isotopes and the inability to accurately measure atomic masses at the time caused some discrepancies in the arrangement.

  2. Omission of Noble Gases: Mendeleev's periodic table did not include noble gases because they were not yet discovered at the time of its creation. As a result, the periodic table did not account for these elements with unique properties, such as their inertness and full valence electron shells.

  3. Positioning of Hydrogen: Mendeleev faced challenges in determining the appropriate placement of hydrogen in the periodic table due to its unique properties. He ultimately placed hydrogen in Group 1 alongside alkali metals, even though hydrogen shares some similarities with Group 17 elements (halogens) as well.

  4. Incompleteness and Gaps: The periodic table developed by Mendeleev contained gaps for elements that had not yet been discovered. While Mendeleev successfully predicted the properties of some of these missing elements, such as gallium and germanium, the periodic table was not fully comprehensive or systematic.

  5. Limited Explanation of Periodicity: Mendeleev's periodic table provided a systematic arrangement of elements but did not offer a comprehensive explanation for the observed periodic trends, such as variations in atomic radius, electronegativity, and ionization energy across periods and groups.

  6. Failure to Account for Electron Configuration: Mendeleev's periodic table did not consider the electronic configuration of atoms, which plays a crucial role in determining the chemical properties of elements. The modern periodic table organizes elements based on increasing atomic number and electron configuration, providing a more accurate representation of their properties and behavior.

Overall, while Mendeleev's periodic table laid the foundation for understanding the relationships between elements, its limitations and drawbacks necessitated the development of the modern periodic table, which is based on atomic number and provides a more systematic and comprehensive framework for organizing and studying the elements.

 
 
 
read less
Comments

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons


How to Remember first 20 elements of periodic table?
So this is the trick I learnt during myu schooloing period, now I spread to my students. Atomic Number Element Phonic word(Bold are symbol of Element) 1 Hydrogen Hi 2 Helium Hello ...


Periodic table
The elements are classified as S P D F blocks based which shells there valance electrons enters. When we comparing the periodic properties Atomic size : As no shells increases size also will increases...

Recommended Articles

Learning for every child starts from a very young age. While the formal methods include school curriculums and private lessons, the informal methods include dancing, music, drawing, and various fun-filling activities. Playing games and practising these types of activities helps the children get out of boredom and...

Read full article >

Once over with the tenth board exams, a heavy percentage of students remain confused between the three academic streams they have to choose from - science, arts or commerce. Some are confident enough to take a call on this much in advance. But there is no worry if as a student you take time to make choice between - science,...

Read full article >

Quality education does not only help children to get a successful career and life, but it also hugely contributes to society. The formal education of every child starts from school. Although there are numerous schools, parents find it challenging to choose the right one that would fit their child. It is difficult for them...

Read full article >

While schools provide formal education to the children, the home is where they start learning about things informally. Parents think that schools will take the initiative to educate their children. Well, this is partially true, as parents also play an essential role in bringing up their child. For the development of particular...

Read full article >

Looking for Class 11 Tuition ?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you
X

Looking for Class 11 Tuition Classes?

The best tutors for Class 11 Tuition Classes are on UrbanPro

  • Select the best Tutor
  • Book & Attend a Free Demo
  • Pay and start Learning

Take Class 11 Tuition with the Best Tutors

The best Tutors for Class 11 Tuition Classes are on UrbanPro

This website uses cookies

We use cookies to improve user experience. Choose what cookies you allow us to use. You can read more about our Cookie Policy in our Privacy Policy

Accept All
Decline All

UrbanPro.com is India's largest network of most trusted tutors and institutes. Over 55 lakh students rely on UrbanPro.com, to fulfill their learning requirements across 1,000+ categories. Using UrbanPro.com, parents, and students can compare multiple Tutors and Institutes and choose the one that best suits their requirements. More than 7.5 lakh verified Tutors and Institutes are helping millions of students every day and growing their tutoring business on UrbanPro.com. Whether you are looking for a tutor to learn mathematics, a German language trainer to brush up your German language skills or an institute to upgrade your IT skills, we have got the best selection of Tutors and Training Institutes for you. Read more