pi=circumference/diameter so how could it be irrational?

Asked by Last Modified  

11 Answers

Learn BA Tuition +1 Bio-Mathematics

Follow 1
Answer

Please enter your answer

Bikash Paul

Assistant Professor of Mathematics in Sharda University

Pi=circumference/diameter.But please note that when defining circumference we write 2*pie*r, where r is the radius. What you have written is like one is worshiping Ganges by Ganges.It can be proved that is irrational number which is actually measurement of 180° angel in radians. And definition of rational...
read more
Pi=circumference/diameter.But please note that when defining circumference we write 2*pie*r, where r is the radius. What you have written is like one is worshiping Ganges by Ganges.It can be proved that is irrational number which is actually measurement of 180° angel in radians. And definition of rational numbers is set of all equivalence classes of the numbers a/b such that a is an integer and b a non zero integers so it is not necessary to have 2*pie*r to be rational. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

Yes, pi is a irrational.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

- Circumference=2*pi*r=pi*D. So pi=C/D. - A rational number is one which can be expressed as a/b, where a is an integer and b is a non-zero integer. - pi is an irrational number has been proved by Lambert and Hermite (refer to their proof...it can be explained here but for lack of using mathematical...
read more
- Circumference=2*pi*r=pi*D. So pi=C/D. - A rational number is one which can be expressed as a/b, where a is an integer and b is a non-zero integer. - pi is an irrational number has been proved by Lambert and Hermite (refer to their proof...it can be explained here but for lack of using mathematical expressions...you can contact me if you dont understand the proof). So it is obvious that C/D = pi is irrational. Further you may ask that pi=22/7 is a rational number but if you look closely 22/7="3.142.." but pi="3.141592......"is a non-repeating continuous value . Thus 22/7 is a very close approximation of pi but not the actual value of pi. Hence pi=C/D is irrational. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

A rational number is a ratio of the form a/b where a and b are integers and b is not equal to zero. In the case of pi, the circumference and diameter need not be integers.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

pi= P is irrational which which the number is a non-terminating series of numbers approximating the value to desired level of precision. the circumference of a circle is expressed by the following equation: circumference = 2 P r ; here r is the radius of the circle. let me introduce an analogy. recall...
read more
pi= P is irrational which which the number is a non-terminating series of numbers approximating the value to desired level of precision. the circumference of a circle is expressed by the following equation: circumference = 2 P r ; here r is the radius of the circle. let me introduce an analogy. recall the Bohr model of the atom. the electrons orbit in particular radii. this is quantization-the source of the stability of the atom. this question is trying to introduce the similar situation. the Bohr atom works well explaining the stability of atoms. if P were not to be irrational we would be allowed the construction of some particular circles. this is not the case. we can construct a variety of circles. So there is no problem why P cant be irrational !kindly state the motivation for the question more clearly. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

It is like dividing 1 by 3. Both 1 and 3 are rational, rather integer. But their division gives a result that is non-ending, i.e. 3333....
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

Pi is not exactly circumcise/diameter. It is an approximate of that.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

math magician

While getting value of pie, it is 22/7 where 7 i.e., numerator is a non zero numeral proving pi as rational number.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Trainer

actually it is not a finite terminating value. so it is not rational. so we can say that it is irrational
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Since the value of pi is non-terminating, so its irrational.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

View 9 more Answers

Related Questions

I am looking to teach french online. Can UrbanPro help me?
Sure UrbanPro is a very good platform to get interactions with the students.
Saurabh
What about a good computerized language which I can learn soon?
if you are a beginner then you can start with java because it is in high demand, but you should practice the programs from class 11 and 12 isc books because there are lots of programs to implement, after...
Sabat
How to learn clear English I don't know spoke about English?
Rapidex English Speaking Course.
Monisha
What are the challenges that government will face in removing caste based reservation from education?
Would lose vote bank but actually would increase income disparity
Neel
0 0
8
how am i to get the command on vocabulary?
You must read The Hindu Editor's page with dictionary to see the meaning as well as pronunciation once you are confident enough then read some good novels that's it
Obulesh

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons

What are crucial conversations? How is anger triggered?
Recently I came across a book about Crucial conversations. The language and the content were extremely engaging. I wanted to talk in a series here about some insights that I got from that book. Usually,...
S

Sailakshmi K V

0 0
0
01 Introduction to Computer networks
Introduction to Computer Networks:

Himanshu K.

0 0
0
Manage Your Manager
You may ask me why I need to manage my manager or the way I prefer to call it – Lead my boss? Let’s see why! Because it: Makes your job easy. If she is on your side, your chances of climbing...

Ritu M.

0 0
0
Telomeres (Boon or Curse)!
It's undoubtedly a boon, but in some context (cancer), it has to be considered as a curse.Replication of DNA is one of the essential and eminent processes of the central dogma of life. This occurs in both...

Surekha T.

0 0
0
Dialogue - Conversation between a Tree and a Human Being
Dialogue - Conversation between a Tree and a Human Being Tree: Hi, Human Being, How are you? I hope you are well.Human Being: I am fine, thank you and how are you?Tree: I’m not fine at all....

Brian T

Recommended Articles

7 key skills to develop while you are in college

Whatever you learn in college is no doubt very important and forms the base for your future professional career. However, lack of hands-on experience, business oriented skills and interpersonal skills, among fresh graduates are making them unfit for employment in competitive business environment. Today organizations operate...

Read full article >

10 Tips For Your College Dissertation Project

Whether you are doing graduation or post graduation, no college student can escape from the misery of college dissertation. College dissertation is a detailed research project on a topic of your choice, approved by professors. At the beginning of the dissertation you have to set a hypothetical aim and at the end, you have...

Read full article >

6 Bachelor of Arts (BA) Subjects That Promise...

Most of the students decide what stream they are going to choose at the school level. Science, commerce and arts are the main fields, and students need to choose any one between these three. Although there are many such professional courses available, most students like to select one of these three streams. In college,...

Read full article >

Common Rules to Follow for College Students

During the last days in school, every student waits for their college life. It is, of course, exciting to get admission in your dream college with the course you wanted to pursue. Its your effort and struggle that makes you part of the college that you aimed for. Yet, once the first month passes all students forget their...

Read full article >

Find BA Tuition near you
BA Tuition in Delhi
BA Tuition in Bangalore
BA Tuition in Kolkata
BA Tuition in Hyderabad
BA Tuition in Mumbai
BA Tuition in Chennai
BA Tuition in Pune
BA Tuition in Noida
BA Tuition in Chandigarh
BA Tuition in Gurgaon

Looking for BA Tuition ?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you