What is the difference between carnatic and hindustani music?

Asked by Last Modified  

14 Answers

Follow 11
Answer

Please enter your answer

Supriti Sinha

Having 10 years of experience.. Bhaskar (m.a)Kathak dance and vocal classical music.,

Somany differences.. Few n mainly difference is 1. Language difference 2. In Hindustani music taal follow the rag. But in carnatic music raag follow taal.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Hindustani classical vocal teacher and trainer

Hindustani classical music and carnatic is different of singing style but raag is same swar of both
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Bharatanatyam dancer with 7+ years of teaching experience.

Hindustani music is raga based music and carnatic is Kirti based music. If we see both the history carnatic is originated in the bakti movement and hindustani is originated during vedic period. And also we can say that carnatic is homogeneous and hindustani is heterogeneous. Usually hindustani music...
read more
Hindustani music is raga based music and carnatic is Kirti based music. If we see both the history carnatic is originated in the bakti movement and hindustani is originated during vedic period. And also we can say that carnatic is homogeneous and hindustani is heterogeneous. Usually hindustani music belongs from northern region and carnatic music is from souther region. Carnatic bit tough to learn as it is gamakas and kirti based music. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

A professional singer, instructor and music composer. Belongs to Dilli Gharana of Music.

The main difference is that the Hindustani Music Is Raag-based and the Carnatic Music Is Kriti-based.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

I'm a Carnatic music trainer

There is no too much of different both are same but the way of singing and gamakas are different.. Carnatic music hv so many ragas ,gamakas and different talas.. But hindustani music hv little bit of ragas and talas like mrng ragas etc that's it..listen one carnatic music bhairavi ata tala varna and...
read more
There is no too much of different both are same but the way of singing and gamakas are different.. Carnatic music hv so many ragas ,gamakas and different talas.. But hindustani music hv little bit of ragas and talas like mrng ragas etc that's it..listen one carnatic music bhairavi ata tala varna and listen hindustani kruthis so u can idenfies that's differences between carnatic music and hindustani music... Actually it's brilliant question u asking may be u satisfied my answer tq ashwini... read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Musician

Music is no difference style of singing is diffrence pronouncing and taking pause is Difference if you understand correctly
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Professional Study of Music From Bhatkhande Music University

Both are the forms of Classical Music , the basic difference between both is that , the style and way of singing the raags are different and the composition or bandish is different in both the forms .
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Music Teacher

To make it very easy Carnatic is South Indian music style and hindustani is North Indian style of music but they are very similar both use same s r g m p d n s and I think the main difference is in the ornamentation. In carnatic music we have thousands of ragas and 35 different talams are there on the...
read more
To make it very easy Carnatic is South Indian music style and hindustani is North Indian style of music but they are very similar both use same s r g m p d n s and I think the main difference is in the ornamentation. In carnatic music we have thousands of ragas and 35 different talams are there on the other hand hindustani has good number of ragas and talas and there are many equivalent ragas you can find between these two styles if we go more deep analysing it goes on and on but if you ask me to put it in laymen's terms I would say carnatic music is complex and rich and technically brilliant and hindustani is little bit simple and more melodious with having all of those important technical elements I think this might be helpful for you Thank you read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Experienced and friendly tutor

hindustani music has more alaps. pitch is also given priority in hindustani. false note at high pitch is something frowned upon. carnatic concentrates on kritis whereas hindustani has music from different gharanas
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Online Carnatic Music and Violin Classes

Both are different at the same time similar, some ragas are borrowed from the other which can be understood once you start learning any one this type of music.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

View 12 more Answers

Related Questions

I am 24 years old. I want to build my career in singing. I am an untrained singer and wanted to be a playback singer. What should I do from the beginner level? Should I learn Carnatic music or something else? Please share your valuable feedback.
Hello ashish if you want to be a playback singer in bollywood you just need to start learning in indian classical music...it will be become ur base strong..nd side by side u should practice bollywood songs..nd ur effort is must for singing...
Asish
I'm learning Carnatic music, and I also want to learn piano which is a western influence. Is it okay to mix both of the genres?
If you study both means.you first understand notation it will help to achieve you music aim
Rakesh
0 0
8
I want to teach carnatic music online let me know how can I do this?
I think Mr.Vinod said it all
Sri
How can I download the class 12 vocal music book in PDF?
You can download them from national institute of open schooling website or saampradayam website. You can also contact me for the proper booklet.
Deepthi
0 0
6
am 22 year old can i learn carnatic vocal music . is it suitable fr me?
Art suits any age. Ekagratha is important.
Nagendra

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons

12 Chakras of Classical Indian Music
12 Chakras of Classical Indian Music.Melakarta ragas are fundamental ragas from which other ragas may be generated. For this reason the melakarta ragas arealso known as janaka (parent) ragas. Melakarta...

Vinod

1 0
0
Palta (pattern) for Indian Classical music

Aniket Barua

0 0
0
Palta (pattern) for Indian Classical music

Aniket Barua

0 0
0
Kharaj Practice in Correct Way
1. Standing note / Long Note Practice in Mandra Saptak (Lower Octave) 2. Need to Stay on a particular Note for a full Breath 3. So Kharaj Practice in different Vowels of Hindi 4. Gargling gives better...

Subhradeep S.

0 0
0
Raga and its Effects.
Raga and its Effects: Raga Pooriya Dhansari (Hamsanandi-Kamavardini ) - Evokes sweet, deep, heavy and stable state of mind and prevents acidity.Raga Bageshri – Arouses a feeling of darkness, stability,...

Vinod

2 0
0

Recommended Articles

Choosing the right guitar -- Before you take...

by Kiran Roy, Guitar Hall - The Guitar Boutique Most importantly, only select a guitar you know is fully inspected and adjusted for easy playability, accuracy in tuning, intonation and tone production. Many important issues rest on the quality and playability of your instrument. Always get the facts. Ask what has...

Read full article >

5 Ways Music Benefits Children

Music is an entertainment source for everyone but for some, it is the greatest form of art. Music is wings to the mind and flight to the creativity as it builds up self-confidence, enhances mood and sprinkles creativity to a child. In fact, musical experiences in childhood can speed up brain development, learning language...

Read full article >

Meet Arpan Sen, a Guitar trainer from Kolkata

Arpan  Sen is a guitar trainer with nearly 14 years of experience. He has worked with renowned Indian tabla maestro, Bickram Ghosh. He also has collaboration with Irish flautist, John Devitt. Arpan has been associated with several prominent music institutions for several years. As a tunesmith, he dabbles in sounds and weaves...

Read full article >

Learn the Coolest Musical Instrument "Guitar"

The genuine monarch of music instrument for centuries, Guitar is renowned for its prodigious aristocracy, versatility and its individuality that stand on its own. Necessitated from the mildest resonant melodic night to the heavy metal rock concert, this string instrument called “Guitar” has gained its popularity among everyone....

Read full article >

Find Vocal Music classes near you
Vocal Music classes in Bangalore
Vocal Music classes in Delhi
Vocal Music classes in Chennai
Vocal Music classes in Kolkata
Vocal Music classes in Mumbai
Vocal Music classes in Hyderabad
Vocal Music classes in Pune
Vocal Music classes in Lucknow
Vocal Music classes in Gurgaon
Vocal Music classes in Noida
Online Vocal Music Classes

Looking for Vocal Music classes?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you