Historically, was the (pre-) Proto-Germanic language a branch more related to Balto-Slavic or to Italo-Celtic languages? How credible is the assumption that Germanic arose as a mixed language between western Italo-Celtic and eastern Balto-Slavic?

Asked by Last Modified  

1 Answer

Follow 1
Answer

Please enter your answer

First of all, the German language is not considered a mixed language because mixed languages often have simplified grammar. But, when it comes to German, as a language, grammar is much more complex and has a long history of rich culture and vocabulary. However, one can’t deny the fact that there...
read more
First of all, the German language is not considered a mixed language because mixed languages often have simplified grammar. But, when it comes to German, as a language, grammar is much more complex and has a long history of rich culture and vocabulary. However, one can’t deny the fact that there are some features which German has in common with the Balto-Slavic languages. To explain it precisely, there are mainly two haplogroups (genes, or DNA type in ordinary language) namely R1a and R1b. Primarily, the modern German belong to R1b, whereas the Slavs belong to R1a. There were several ways in which these groups came to western Europe. R1b came through Gibraltar to the Perinean Peninsula and R1a - from Anatolia to the Carpathian Mountains. Although it is difficult to answer as they took different paths, the words might have derived from different languages as well. It is said that German, modern Russian and Latvian words are the closest to Sanskrit words. It is also believed that Germans borrowed their language from eastern neighbours tribes. Hope this helps! read less
Comments

Related Questions

I need a German teacher in sector -4 Gurgaon for A-2 level .. Teacher should be from Gurgaon preferably..
I am putting up in Sector 14, Gurgaon. If you want to take german language classes , contact me.
Profile Photo
Neha
Can any body suggest, which institute is good for certified German language courses?
You can learn German from any good teacher. Read reviews before you select a teacher. You can always write exams from Goethe and get recognized certificate. This is a preferred approach. This way, you...
Profile Photo
Sandip
What are taught in German basics?
Lesson 1 - Konjugation Präsens, Personalpronomen I Lesson 2 - Bestimmter und unbestimmter Artikel I Lesson 3 - Bestimmter und unbestimmter Artikel II Lesson 4 - Modalverben Lesson 5 - Personalpronomen...
Profile Photo
Annu
Which is the best place to learn German in and around Indiranagar (Bangalore) apart from Goethe Institute?
The best place to learn any language will be a place, where you get to learn lot of new peoples, where you can read lots of books, where you can see videos. You can practice speaking with local as well...
Profile Photo
Gagan
0 0
View Comments7
Which foreign language is most demanding language?
A few ofcourse. However I would like to put it in other words. It depends on your Domain. As one chooses a foreign language as an application in his domain. For eg. German or Japanese is the best for mechanical...
Profile Photo
The Lingual Successes

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons


German Counting
Die Zahlen Numbers null zero eins one zwei two drei three vier four fünf five sechs six sieben seven acht eight neun nine zehn ten elf eleven zwölf twelve dreizehn thirteen vierzehn fourteen fünfzehn fifteen sechzehn sixteen siebzehn seventeen achtzehn eighteen neunzehn nineteen zwanzig twenty einundzwanzig twenty-one dreißig thirty vierzig forty fünfzig fifty sechzig sixty siebzig seventy achtzig eighty neunzig ninety hundert one...
Profile Photo

Imperative Sentences in German
1. Formal CommandThis is the imperative that we learned in Chapter One, the Sie-command. When you address one OR several people in a formal manner, you must use this form. The verb takes the -en ending...
Profile Photo

German Made Easy - Gender Rules : A Must For Learners.
We know that there are three genders in the German language: Masculine, Feminine and Neuter. The articles for them are der, die and das respectively. It is important in German you know the gender of a...
Profile Photo

DETERMINING THE GENDER - with Examples
DETERMINING THE GENDER To ease the matter further for you, I am including here some rules and some hints to know and to make out the gender of the nouns in German. Please note that these rules and hints...
Profile Photo

Recommended Articles

In today’s era of globalization, English as the primary official language has lost much of its sheen. Regional languages are much in demand and with countries like China, Japan and Korea making their presence felt in the international scenario, the career prospects for a Language Translator have increased multifold. Translation...

Read full article >

When globalization was out of picture, it was enough to know just the mother tongue. Since globalization and out-sourcing have become part of life, there is a nagging need to learn new languages. Foreign languages help us to communicate with potential clients, sell our ideas and bond with their culture. It could be opening...

Read full article >

Bilingual candidates are high in demand in multinational corporations around the world. Today, we live in a fast-paced life where business dynamics are changing every day. So organisations need people who have the right language skills and trending technical knowledge to meet and solve business requirements. Candidates...

Read full article >

If you think English is enough to communicate with anybody in this world, you are sadly misinformed. Statistically the highest spoken foreign language in the world is Chinese with 20.7%, followed by English at 6.2%. That means that 93.8% of people do not speak English. This makes it necessary to learn another foreign language...

Read full article >

Looking for German Language Classes?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you