Why, Wurtz reaction is limited to the synthesis of symmetric alkanes ?

Asked by Last Modified  

29 Answers

Follow 3
Answer

Please enter your answer

Sapna Kumari

Chemistry Wizard/English Expert

Because the product will be a mixture of alkanes which is difficult to separate.For unsymmetrical alkane use COREY HOUSE Reaction
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Physics and Maths made easy

Wurtz reaction can also be used for the reaction of 2 different alkyl halides. But there will be 3 different products formed due to 3 different possible reactions that occur. For example consider iodomethane (CH3-I) and iodoethane (CH3-CH2-I) and you want to prepare propane by Wurtz reaction then these...
read more
Wurtz reaction can also be used for the reaction of 2 different alkyl halides. But there will be 3 different products formed due to 3 different possible reactions that occur. For example consider iodomethane (CH3-I) and iodoethane (CH3-CH2-I) and you want to prepare propane by Wurtz reaction then these reactions will take place: CH3-I + 2Na + I-CH2-CH3 -----> CH3-CH2-CH3 + 2NaI CH3-I + 2Na + I-CH3 -----> CH3-CH3 + 2NaI CH3-CH2-I + 2Na + I-CH2-CH3 ------> CH3-CH2-CH2-CH3 + 2NaI The products formed ( propane, ethane and butane ) have very less difference in their boiling points. Therefore it will be difficult to separate the products with fractional distillation. It is because of this reason that only symmetrical alkanes are generally synthesized using wurtz reaction. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Tutor

Mechanism of the simple Wurtz reaction. R---X + 2Na -----> (R)-(Na)+ this (R)- joins the 'R' from another R----X molecule and the (Na) joins the X part giving R----R + NaX. Thus you are able to create only symmetric alkanes. If you use two different alkyl halides then a mixture with small percentage...
read more
Mechanism of the simple Wurtz reaction. R---X + 2Na -----> (R)-(Na)+ this (R)- joins the 'R' from another R----X molecule and the (Na) joins the X part giving R----R + NaX. Thus you are able to create only symmetric alkanes. If you use two different alkyl halides then a mixture with small percentage of unsymmetric alkanes are produced but because of their very similar boiling points and their physical properties they cannot be separated and thus Wurtz reaction is not good for producing unsymmetric alkanes. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Chemistry for CBSE,STAE ,ISC AND IIT-JEE,MH-CET,PMT and all other level +12 competitive level exam.

If we use the unsymmetrical alkyle halide their is probability to formation of byproducts which is very difficult to separate from reaction mix,as the boiling point of these product is very similar.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Chemistry Tutor

if two different alkyl halogens are reacting with Na, then the formation of two or more alkanes may form, since its due to formation of two different radicals and it is also noted that the formed products (Alkanes) are very closed billing points, hence its difficult to separate from the mixture.
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

B.Sc, M.Sc, Ph.D, MBA (Finance and Marketing)

In wurtz reaction if take a single haloalkane as reactant it gives symmetric alkanes but if two or more different haloalkanes r taken it results in mixture of alkanes (symmetric and asymmetric) and they r difficult to separate even through fractional distillation. Becoz they form azeotropic mixture...
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Engineer

The Wurtz reaction is limited to synthesis of symmetrical alkanes with even number of carbon atoms only. The number of carbons in the alkane is double that of alkyl halide (n ---> 2n type reaction) If dissimilar alky halides are used, a mixture of alkanes is formed. It is usually difficult to separate...
read more
The Wurtz reaction is limited to synthesis of symmetrical alkanes with even number of carbon atoms only. The number of carbons in the alkane is double that of alkyl halide (n ---> 2n type reaction) If dissimilar alky halides are used, a mixture of alkanes is formed. It is usually difficult to separate the mixture and hence wurtz reaction not a suitable method to synthesize unsymmetrical alkanes. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

In Wurtz reaction, two alkyl halide molecules are coupled in presence of sodium metal in anhydrous ether or Tetrahydrofuran to form a new carbon carbon bond and thus by giving a symmetrical alkane. Dry Ether R-X + 2Na + X-R -----------------> R-R + 2NaX Where X = halogen * The Wurtz reaction must...
read more
In Wurtz reaction, two alkyl halide molecules are coupled in presence of sodium metal in anhydrous ether or Tetrahydrofuran to form a new carbon carbon bond and thus by giving a symmetrical alkane. Dry Ether R-X + 2Na + X-R -----------------> R-R + 2NaX Where X=halogen * The Wurtz reaction must be performed under anhydrous conditions because the alkyl free radical formed (see the mechanism) during the reaction is strongly basic and can abstract proton from water. * In case of alkyl and aryl fluorides as well as aryl chlorides, tetrahydrofuran is used as solvent instead of ether. * The Wurtz reaction is limited to synthesis of symmetrical alkanes with even number of carbon atoms only. The number of carbons in the alkane is double that of alkyl halide (n ---> 2n type reaction) * If dissimilar alky halides are used, a mixture of alkanes is formed. It is usually difficult to separate the mixture and hence wurtz reaction not a suitable method to synthesize unsymmetrical alkanes. E.g. The Wurtz reaction between R-X and R'-X yields not only R-R' but also R-R and R'-R'. This mixture cannot be separated easily. * Methane cannot be prepared by this method. * A modification of this reaction involving alkyl and aryl halides is called Wurtz-Fittig reaction. If only aryl halides are subjected to coupling, the reaction is called as Fittig reaction. read less
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

Msc

this is known as one of the drawbacks of Wurtz reaction.The reasons are- 1. If assymetrical alkanes are used with odd numer of carbon atoms they react with each other as well as among themselves producing a mixture of three alkanes.Example- CH3-I + 2Na + I-CH2-CH3 -----> CH3-CH2-CH3 + 2NaI CH3-I...
read more
this is known as one of the drawbacks of Wurtz reaction.The reasons are- 1. If assymetrical alkanes are used with odd numer of carbon atoms they react with each other as well as among themselves producing a mixture of three alkanes.Example- CH3-I + 2Na + I-CH2-CH3 -----> CH3-CH2-CH3 + 2NaI CH3-I + 2Na + I-CH3 -----> CH3-CH3 + 2NaI CH3-CH2-I + 2Na + I-CH2-CH3 ------> CH3-CH2-CH2-CH3 + 2NaI 2. Moreover these alkanes cannot be separated (as they have high boiling points) by fractional distillation. Hope this will help you. read less
1 Comments
Dislike Bookmark

difficult to separate as the difference in the boiling points of the products is very low in these cases, making distillation unusable. Also, since the reaction involves free radical species, a side reaction occurs to produce an alkene
Comments
Dislike Bookmark

View 27 more Answers

Related Questions

what is the full form of IGCSE?
It is " International General Certificate of Secondary Education."
Rutvik
How can I excel physics?
One can excel in any subject by properly studying and doing practicals .
Bikram
0 0
7
A can do a work in 15 days and B in 20 days. If they work on it together for 4 days, then the fraction of the work that is left is : A.1/4 B.1/10 C.7/15 D.8/15
A's 1 day work=1/15, B's= 1/20, Combined 1-day work=(1/15 + 1/20= 7/60); Combined 4 day's work= 28/60, therefore work left=(1-28/60)=32/60 or 8/15
Srikanth
0 0
6
What is the value of sin(360)?
0
Suman
how to clear KARNATAKA PUC MATHS IN ONE MONTH(old syllabus)
No way you can cover a Math syllabus in 1 Month. Yet, you can try by starting each chapter with writing down the formula. Solve Algebra then graph then theorem then tree, mapping scheme and so on. You...
Rockysourabh
0 0
5

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons

Introduction to Trial Balance & its Components
Aims And Objectives At the end of the lesson you be able to: Understand of Sundry Debtors Understanding of Sundry Creditors Understanding of Basics of Trial balance Introduction All...

Dev Group

1 0
1
Cash Flow Statement
Purpose of a statement of cash flows: To provide information about the cash inflows and outflows of an entity during a period. To summarize the operating, investing, and financing activities of the...

Ravi Yadav

0 0
0
Method of Mathematical Induction
Method of Mathematical Induction ******************************* In Mathematical Induction, first we prove it for n=1. Then assume it to work for n=k. Prove that it works for n=k+1. For example let...

Kumaresh Natarajan

0 0
0
Easy way to study organic reactions
You know it is always tough that to study organic reaction without a simple mistake. There is no trick way to study them fast. But there is an easy way to remember some of the reactions. Study the various...

Vivek P S

0 0
0
Class XII - Continuity

Akhil Roy

0 0
0

Recommended Articles

Meet Radhe Shyam Burman, an MBA Tutor from...

Radhe Shyam is a highly skilled accounts and finance trainer with 8 years of experience in teaching. Accounting is challenging for many students and that’s where Radhe Shyam’s expertise comes into play. He helps his students not only in understanding the subject but also advises them on how to overcome the fear of accounts...

Read full article >

Meet Raghunandan.G.H, a B. Tech Tutor from...

Raghunandan is a passionate teacher with a decade of teaching experience. Being a skilled trainer with extensive knowledge, he provides high-quality BTech, Class 10 and Class 12 tuition classes. His methods of teaching with real-time examples makes difficult topics simple to understand. He explains every concept in-detail...

Read full article >

Meet Swati, a Hindi Tutor from Bangalore

Swati is a renowned Hindi tutor with 7 years of experience in teaching. She conducts classes for various students ranging from class 6- class 12 and also BA students. Having pursued her education at Madras University where she did her Masters in Hindi, Swati knows her way around students. She believes that each student...

Read full article >

Meet Mohammad Wazid, a skilled trainer for...

Mohammad Wazid is a certified professional tutor for class 11 students. He has 6 years of teaching experience which he couples with an energetic attitude and a vision of making any subject easy for the students. Over the years he has developed skills with a capability of understanding the requirements of the students. This...

Read full article >

Find Class 12 Tuition near you
Class 12 Tuition in Delhi
Class 12 Tuition in Bangalore
Class 12 Tuition in Hyderabad
Class 12 Tuition in Chennai
Class 12 Tuition in Kolkata
Class 12 Tuition in Mumbai
Class 12 Tuition in Pune
Class 12 Tuition in Noida
Class 12 Tuition in Lucknow
Class 12 Tuition in Gurgaon
Online Tuition Class 12

Looking for Class 12 Tuition ?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you