Can anyone learn both western and Indian classical music?

Asked by Last Modified  

Follow 2
Answer

Please enter your answer

Trainer

Definitely not vocal. The muscles used and the way sound is produced are different. Instrumental can be learned but should be done one at a time. If you master one, second will be easier. The underlying notes and beats are same. Where western has chords, Indian has complex rhythm cycles. Jazz is closest...
read more
Definitely not vocal. The muscles used and the way sound is produced are different. Instrumental can be learned but should be done one at a time. If you master one, second will be easier. The underlying notes and beats are same. Where western has chords, Indian has complex rhythm cycles. Jazz is closest to Indian clasical. read less
Comments

Passionate and committed music educator educated abroad!

Yes, of course! In fact, the strengths of both western and Indian classical music can be leveraged to learn faster and to create a strong musical foundation. The world has numerous musical traditions, genres, styles etc, but ultimately there is a certain musical unity in diversity which can enrich a...
read more
Yes, of course! In fact, the strengths of both western and Indian classical music can be leveraged to learn faster and to create a strong musical foundation. The world has numerous musical traditions, genres, styles etc, but ultimately there is a certain musical unity in diversity which can enrich a person as he keeps adding to his or her repertoire of music. It is a unique joy and adds unique value to our lives, Even the most popular bands in western music such as "Beatles", "Shakti" incorporated Indian music in some of their songs and compositions. Although I teach western music, the knowledge of Indian classical music, especially Carnatic rhythms has immensely helped me in getting a strong grasp of complex rhythms used in western music. Also, some of the arpeggios I play on the guitar remind me of certain Indian Ragas viz Hansadhwani, Marwa etc. So, go ahead! I'd strongly encourage you to learn both western and Indian classical music. All the Best! read less
Comments

Best Professional Music Academy in Delhi / NCR

Yes As both have similarities n dissimilarities but after comparison u will get a point where u r free to do both sideways
Comments

M.SC(MATHS), TRINITY COLLEGE OF LONDON CERTIFIED.

sure...if u can practice 8hrs daily (4+4) atleast 2yrs...and make sure that it should continuous without breaks...and believe in ur self..dont give up...good luck
Comments

Teacher, Trainer & Composer

Yes you can. But it will be better to learn the western music first and then go in for the Indian music. That way you will understand the Indian melodic patterns (ragas) easily and not get confused between a Raga and a Scale.
Comments

Carnatic Vocal Music with 10 year of experienced and certified Vocal instructor

Definitely why not it's a good idea
Comments

Keyboardist

yes why not?
Comments

Musician

absolutely!
Comments

B.Sc(Mathematics) from St. Xaviers College, Mumbai

Of course. There are many examples of that- many fusion artists and bands have precisely done that. The Raghu Dixit Project and Indian Ocean are popular examples.
Comments

Musician And Genuine Teacher.

yes...difference is only in style
Comments

View 52 more Answers

Related Questions

How much time it takes to learn western classical music?
With a professional teacher, who knows the technique n experience of singing opera and if you work nicely you'll start getting good results in a year.
Profile Photo
Soumi
0 0
View Comments8
What is the difference between Western classical music and Western contemporary music
Contemporary music is the current generation of music (mostly after 1900). Classical music is ideally everything before that.
Profile Photo
The Guitar T.
0 0
View Comments6

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons

Practice Song
Playing a song or singing a song is a bit different than technical exercises which are much difficult to do long hours, so before practising a student must fix his mind to think that he will give his fixed...
Profile Photo

Pieces
Teachers typically assign the student pieces (or songs for vocal students) of slowly increasing difficulty. Besides using pieces to teach various musical rudiments (rhythm, harmony, pitch, etc.) and teach...
Profile Photo

Basic Breathing Exercises for better Singing, Tip-12
Do it Excercise : Yell “hey” (one hand on your belly) with an open feeling in your throat as if you were calling to someoneacross a large room. Notice how your lower body supports your voice....
Profile Photo

Theory And History
To fully understand music being played, the student must learn the basics of the underlying music theory. Along with musical notation, students learn rhythmic techniques like controlling tempo, recognizing...
Profile Photo

Saptak
Seven swaras sa re ga ma pa dha ni altogether called saptak. There are 3 saptak mandra, madhya and taar mandra saptak means lower octav madhya saptak is mid and higher octave is called taar saptak.
Profile Photo

Looking for Western Vocal Music Classes ?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you