we know from our experiments that, the element attained octet ( Noble gas configuration) is always stable. but why 8 is the stability no....why not any thing else..what is the physical/ electric reason for that.

Asked by Last Modified  

12 Answers

Follow 0
Answer

Please enter your answer

Chemistry tutor with yrs of experience in professional R&D

Most of these answers seem to be effectively saying, "8 electrons form a stable shell because the valence shell has 8 slots and a full shell is the most stable configuration," but I think the real question being asked is, "why does the valence shell have 8 slots in the first place?" Although the presence...
read more
Most of these answers seem to be effectively saying, "8 electrons form a stable shell because the valence shell has 8 slots and a full shell is the most stable configuration," but I think the real question being asked is, "why does the valence shell have 8 slots in the first place?" Although the presence of 8 slots is often taught as if it were a purely empirical observation (probably because, historically, it was for a long time), it can actually be derived from the axioms of quantum mechanics and the geometry of 3-dimensional space. Below is an overview of some of the relevant features of the derivation. If you solve Schroedinger's equation for an electron in the potential well of a nucleus, you can find every possible bound state that the electron could possibly have. Finding the solution involves making sure that the electron's wavefunction repeats itself at intervals that allow it to "fit" around the nucleus. By analogy, consider a wave on a length of string. It has peaks and troughs at a certain period. The goal is to find which periods (wavelengths) will "fit" on the string, such that if you bring the two ends of the string together to form a loop around the nucleus, there will be no discontinuities in the wave. The resulting waves are called harmonics: A loop is sufficient to wrap around a point in a 2 dimensional plane, but electrons and atoms exist in 3 dimensions. Hence, we have to make sure the electron's wavefunction "fits" in both of the two angular degrees of freedom around a point in 3 dimensions. The waves that "fit" around a central point in 3 dimensions are called spherical harmonics: Since there are two angular degrees of freedom around a point in 3 dimensions, it takes two numbers to identify a given solution that fits. As a result, there are a total of three numbers needed to fully identify a wavefunction solution: n: quantization in energy l (lowercase L): quantization in first angular degree of freedom m: quantization in second angular degree of freedom Purely from the math of the solution and the rules of geometry, one finds that the following rules must be satisfied in order for the solution to fit: n must be a positive integer (1, 2, 3, ...) for a given n, l can be any integer from 0 to n-1 inclusive for a given l, m can be any integer from -l to l inclusive In addition, the properties of the electron dictate that: for a given n, l, and m, there are two possible electron states: one for spin up and one for spin down Putting all these rules together, we can count the number of "slots" available for electrons to fill up a given shell. For the lowest energy shell (n=1), l can be any integer from 0 to 0. That is, it can only be 0. In turn, for l=0, m can be only -0 to 0, meaning it can also only be 0. This means there is only one allowed combination with n=1, namely the one where n=1, l=0, and m=0. Since electrons can be spin up or spin down, this means there are 2 total slots available. This is why hydrogen and helium are stable with 2 electrons -- because those 2 electrons fill the n=1 shell. For the next energy shell (n=2), l can be 0 to 1. For l=0, m can be only 0. For l=1, m can be -1, 0, or 1. This forms the following set of allowed values: n=2, l=0, m=0 n=2, l=1, m=-1 n=2, l=1, m=0 n=2, l=1, m=1 Since there are 4 allowed values, the shell has 8 slots for electrons (accounting for spin). read less
Comments

I Assure Better Knowledge

No its not necessary that every element needs eight electron in their outermost shell to be stable,actually it follows by almost all s- and p-block elements and both the orbitals can have maximum number of eight electron(s+p=8 electrons) so that they follow it. This octet rule does not work for d- and...
read more
No its not necessary that every element needs eight electron in their outermost shell to be stable,actually it follows by almost all s- and p-block elements and both the orbitals can have maximum number of eight electron(s+p=8 electrons) so that they follow it. This octet rule does not work for d- and f-block elements as they show various stable oxidation states. read less
Comments

Professional Tutor with 15 years of experience.

Thank u Every one . Umesh and Hemanth....You recognized the essence of Question more accurately. Thank for your ans... Please suggest - How can we explain( make them convince) this concept to 9th and 10th Std students...
Comments

We consider 8 octave as stable configuration because this configuration belongs to inter gas which are electicaly neutral and does not react with any other element, hence other element combine to complete their octave
Comments

It comes from quantum numbers s, p, d, f. When you solve for subshells , a Formula 2n^2 pops out which gives 8 on n =2. That is why 8 is a stable configuration.
Comments

FOR 8 ELECTRON IN THE OUTERMOST ORBIT THEY ARE ELECTRICALLY INACTIVE i.e::neither donate or take electron e.g:NEON,ARGON,CRYPTON
Comments

Teaching Expert.

Stability is depends upon the maximum vacant places in the outermost shell. which is as 2,8,18,32,...... So, in case of hydrogen the number is 2 and other than hydrogen 8. To maintain the stability each atom reacts to complete 8, but in case of Noble gases they already have complete octet.
Comments

On completion of octet, an atom acquires minimum potential energy, but in some cases expansion of octet is also observed for example the compounds of sulphur.
Comments

Professional Home Tutor For School Students with 10 Year of Teaching experience

Although the presence of 8 slots is often taught as if it were a purely empirical observation (probably because, historically, it was for a long time), it can actually be derived from the axioms of quantum mechanics and the geometry of 3-dimensional space. Below is an overview of some of the relevant...
read more
Although the presence of 8 slots is often taught as if it were a purely empirical observation (probably because, historically, it was for a long time), it can actually be derived from the axioms of quantum mechanics and the geometry of 3-dimensional space. Below is an overview of some of the relevant features of the derivation. For a more detailed account, I suggest finding a textbook on QM. If you solve Schroedinger's equation for an electron in the potential well of a nucleus, you can find every possible bound state that the electron could possibly have. Finding the solution involves making sure that the electron's wavefunction repeats itself at intervals that allow it to "fit" around the nucleus. By analogy, consider a wave on a length of string. It has peaks and troughs at a certain period. The goal is to find which periods (wavelengths) will "fit" on the string, such that if you bring the two ends of the string together to form a loop around the nucleus, there will be no discontinuities in the wave. The resulting waves are called harmonics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Har... A loop is sufficient to wrap around a point in a 2 dimensional plane, but electrons and atoms exist in 3 dimensions. Hence, we have to make sure the electron's wavefunction "fits" in both of the two angular degrees of freedom around a point in 3 dimensions. The waves that "fit" around a central point in 3 dimensions are called spherical harmonics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sph... Since there are two angular degrees of freedom around a point in 3 dimensions, it takes two numbers to identify a given solution that fits. As a result, there are a total of three numbers needed to fully identify a wavefunction solution: n: quantization in energy l (lowercase L): quantization in first angular degree of freedom m: quantization in second angular degree of freedom Purely from the math of the solution and the rules of geometry, one finds that the following rules must be satisfied in order for the solution to fit: n must be a positive integer (1, 2, 3, ...) for a given n, l can be any integer from 0 to n-1 inclusive for a given l, m can be any integer from -l to l inclusive In addition, the properties of the electron dictate that: for a given n, l, and m, there are two possible electron states: one for spin up and one for spin down Putting all these rules together, we can count the number of "slots" available for electrons to fill up a given shell. For the lowest energy shell (n=1), l can be any integer from 0 to 0. That is, it can only be 0. In turn, for l=0, m can be only -0 to 0, meaning it can also only be 0. This means there is only one allowed combination with n=1, namely the one where n=1, l=0, and m=0. Since electrons can be spin up or spin down, this means there are 2 total slots available. This is why hydrogen and helium are stable with 2 electrons -- because those 2 electrons fill the n=1 shell. For the next energy shell (n=2), l can be 0 to 1. For l=0, m can be only 0. For l=1, m can be -1, 0, or 1. This forms the following set of allowed values: n=2, l=0, m=0 n=2, l=1, m=-1 n=2, l=1, m=0 n=2, l=1, m=1 Since there are 4 allowed values, the shell has 8 slots for electrons (accounting for spin). Copied read less
Comments

Chemistry Home Tutor with effective Assignment series

Because 8 is the no of electrons which fill all the orbitals completely so thus making it unreactive for any kind of bond formation... This is not a perfect rule but do the charm for representative elements.... Also it has many exceptions one and best exception is hydrogen and helium which instead following...
read more
Because 8 is the no of electrons which fill all the orbitals completely so thus making it unreactive for any kind of bond formation... This is not a perfect rule but do the charm for representative elements.... Also it has many exceptions one and best exception is hydrogen and helium which instead following octet rule follow douplet rule... Similarly for transition we do not consider octet rule instead we use 18 electron rule.... Because in them 18 electrons are filled in the penultimate shell..... For further reference Miessler Tarr Inorganic chemistry Shriver atkins Inorganic chemistry read less
Comments

View 10 more Answers

Related Questions

What are the properties of Arithmetic mean?
AM = SUM OF ALL OBSERVATION/TOTAL NO. OF OBSERVATION. A.M = (X1+X2+X3+X4+X5+...........+Xn)/n px1, px2, px3 for this mean.
Anubhav
0 0
7

"व्रतनिधिः '' का क्या अर्थ है |

It's means varth nidi puja path Karne ki vidhi it means procedure of rituals and customs of any kind of worship to god
Rachna
what is dynamic motion ?
Dynamics is a branch of applied mathematics (specifically classical mechanics) concerned with the study of forces and torques and their effect on motion, as opposed to kinematics, which studies the motion...
Shourya
What is Balance of Trade? In which situations is it favourable and unfavourable?
Difference between imports and exports is called the balance of trade. The trade is called favourable if exports exceed imports. The trade is unfavorable if imports exceed exports.
Suresh
0 0
7
Why are rainbows arc shaped?
The reason a rainbow is arc shaped is that a circle is the set of all points in the sky that make the same angle between you, the water droplets, and the sun.
Guru
0 0
6

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons


Find your bestie among the subjects
I feel one can advance in the academics not because of struggling and striving. It's just about learning the concept, not getting into the mind but feeling through the heart. So one can use that when one...
S

Surendra Pasumarthi

0 0
0

Ch 1- Mutliplication short tricks by Ashish Vastri..
1. HOW TO MUTLIPLY 2 digit number by 11? Example 1. 35 * 11 = 385 Step 1. Add both digits of the two digit number. 3+5 = 8. Step 2. Place the result in between both the digits. 3_8_5...

Formation of double bond (oxygen molecule)
Two oxygen atoms combine to form oxygen molecule by sharing two electron pairs. Each oxygen atom (2, 6) has six electrons in the valence shell. It required two electrons to acquire nearest noble gas configuration....

Profit and loss important formulas
IMPORTANT FACTS Cost Price: The price, at which an article is purchased, is called its cost price, abbreviated as C.P. Selling Price: The price, at which an article is sold, is called itsselling prices,...

Recommended Articles

Sandhya is a proactive educationalist. She conducts classes for CBSE, PUC, ICSE, I.B. and IGCSE. Having a 6-year experience in teaching, she connects with her students and provides tutoring as per their understanding. She mentors her students personally and strives them to achieve their goals with ease. Being an enthusiastic...

Read full article >

Mohammad Wazid is a certified professional tutor for class 11 students. He has 6 years of teaching experience which he couples with an energetic attitude and a vision of making any subject easy for the students. Over the years he has developed skills with a capability of understanding the requirements of the students. This...

Read full article >

Quest Academy is a professional Bangalore based NEET and JEE (Main + Advanced) training institute. The academy was incorporated in 2015 to cater to the needs of students, who aim to crack competitive exams by connecting with the best brains around. The institute helps students enhance their skills and capabilities through...

Read full article >

Raghunandan is a passionate teacher with a decade of teaching experience. Being a skilled trainer with extensive knowledge, he provides high-quality BTech, Class 10 and Class 12 tuition classes. His methods of teaching with real-time examples makes difficult topics simple to understand. He explains every concept in-detail...

Read full article >

Looking for Class 10 Tuition ?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you