hello I am an electric guitar player and I wanted to learn vocals so I should go for Indian classical or western?
Asked by Sarthak Last Modified
Follow 20 
Answer 
You should learn classical music because classical music is base; if you learn classically, you also easily sing western or Bollywood or any genre songs.
3
1 Comments
It depends on which kind of music you prefer. If you have the desire to sit for 2hrs and do the proper riyaz only then opt for Indian classical. In western, it depends on how much improvisation you can do with your vocals and the breathing technique where it is very important. Still, if you want my suggestion,...
read more It depends on which kind of music you prefer. If you have the desire to sit for 2hrs and do the proper riyaz only then opt for Indian classical. In western, it depends on how much improvisation you can do with your vocals and the breathing technique where it is very important. Still, if you want my suggestion, I would want you to listen to both performances for urself and then given your vocals decide which will fully satisfy your demand both aesthetically and from your voice quality. I would want you to devote your time to one particular style of music but would recommend you to listen to both performances. It will widen your understanding of music. For example, a folk singer should listen to country music or else he/she will not be able to improvise and hence after a while, his singing style will feel monotonous to the audiences. All the best for your musical journey read less
2
Comments
Indian is the best to learn
1
Comments
If you learn classical music, you can easily sing any song, and also there are so many techs to develop western by learning classical.
0
1 Comments
What you have learnt must be Electric Guitar with a western music base, though you have not sepcified. If you learnt western vocal, it might go with it more comfortable. However the style of singing is also based on what is your overall objective - If you want to become a good singer, and even a lead...
read more What you have learnt must be Electric Guitar with a western music base, though you have not sepcified. If you learnt western vocal, it might go with it more comfortable. However the style of singing is also based on what is your overall objective - If you want to become a good singer, and even a lead singer in many world music groups, Indian style vocal is very very useful, and you can develop excellent skills if you practise v well. We also teach vocals in Carnatic style, and you can also find plenty of good accomplished teachers in your city of residence.Best WishesK Bhaskaran read less
0
2 Comments
You may opt both as both have their respective designations to shape your vocal architecture. And it is always good to explore more styles and be versatile.
0
Comments
Deleted User
Tutor
Indian classical
0
Comments
Go in for both classical and western if you can compartmentalize and learn. Else for electric guitar western vocals will help out more
0
Comments
You can go for both. Western-style singing is more application and technique-based, which will help your application of the technique at ease in your Hindustani singing. Hence it shall help you build a strong base on singing.
0
Comments
View 20 more Answers
Related Questions
What all things should I consider before hiring a Carnatic music teacher? 
First of all a teacher should be able to teach every thing that will be asked by the students.So he or she should be well learned in the subject and have good command on it.A teacher should be sincere in teaching the subject to the student.
5
How does listening to a lot of Carnatic music help one grow as a classical musician?
Listening skill is very important to register the swarasthana or swar placement.Lots of listening will help us to improvise and progress for the advanced lessons
Which is the best raga in Carnatic music?
There isn't a single "best" raga in Carnatic music, as it's a deeply personal and subjective experience, with different ragas evoking different emotions and moods.
Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com
Ask a QuestionRelated Lessons
THE CONCEPT OF "KRIYA" IN TALAM
Any type of Music, in general... is Null and Void, if it is not in strict confirmation to TALAM....or rythem, to put it in a simple way. In Carnatic Music, it is imperative that the students learn the...
V
Learn the Raga Charukesi
Course:Learn to sing in Charukesi Raga Module1:Understand and learn the Raga Charukesi Module2:Sing songs based on Charukesi Raga M1: 1.Understand the Arohanam and Avarohanam of Charukesi Ragam (DNA) 2.Learn...
Basic Breathing Exercises for better Singing, Tip-2
Do it exercise: Sitting in a chair with your feet touching the floor, flop over like a rag doll, with relaxation in your arms, faceand neck, and breathe in this position. See if you can feel the expansion...
V
Learn to sing in Amrithavarshini Raga
Learn the Raga Amrithavarshini Course:Learn to sing in Amrithavarshini Raga Module1:Understand and learn the Raga Amrithavarshini Module2:Sing songs based on Amrithavarshini Raga M1: 1.Understand...
Chaturasra jathi-Druvathalam
SRGM-GR-SRGR-SRGM RGMP-MG-RGMG-RGMP GMPD-PM-GMPM-GMPD MPDN-DP-MPDP-MPDN PDNS-ND-PDND-PDNS SNDP-DN-SNDN-SNDP NDPM-PD-NDPD-NDPM DPMG-MP-DPMP-DPMG PMGR-GM-PMGM-PMGR MGRS-RG-MGRG-MGRS
Find Carnatic Music Classes near you
Looking for Carnatic Music Classes ?
Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro
Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?
Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you
