Please tell me it is possible to folllow time theory in present music education and don't u think by this theory we losses some melodious raagas also.

Asked by Last Modified  

Follow 0
Answer

Please enter your answer

Indian Classical Vocalist, Vocal Music Coach

All ragas are melodious, as you say. While teaching, especially in music institutions, time theory of raga should be put aside for some time, or else one will never be able to complete the syllabus! Classes are held at a given time and a fairly good number of ragas must be taught. Performance is a different...
read more
All ragas are melodious, as you say. While teaching, especially in music institutions, time theory of raga should be put aside for some time, or else one will never be able to complete the syllabus! Classes are held at a given time and a fairly good number of ragas must be taught. Performance is a different story altogether. read less
Comments

Learn Art and Science of Carnatic Classical Music

Time theory is followed strictly only Hindustani classical. In Karnatak music they are not so strict and are allowed to morning ragas like bhouli in the evening concerts. Yes by following time theory we lose our wealth of ragas. Morning midnight afternoon ragas are all lost.
Comments

Tutor

It is not possible.we are not maintain this theory.
Comments

Classical Singer and Harmonium Playing

No.. Personally I don't think so.
Comments

Having more than 15 years experience of Knowledge Sharing

Hi Deepti, Are you concerned about present music education or music performances/recitals ? I shall answer both ways as per my knowledge and experience. Yes, at concerts time theory is still being followed. You may attend concerts and find that almost every artists presents Raga according to the time...
read more
Hi Deepti, Are you concerned about present music education or music performances/recitals ? I shall answer both ways as per my knowledge and experience. Yes, at concerts time theory is still being followed. You may attend concerts and find that almost every artists presents Raga according to the time of performance. About music education, it is not being followed however students are informed about the time theory and specific time for each and every raga. Your point is valid that by following this theory we might loose some of the ragas i.e. late night or early morning or probably the afternoon ragas too. As most if the concerts happen in late evening and only few festivals are whole night or at any other time. But Artists do not perform only at concerts, they also release albums and certainly they have option to consider the odd time ragas in their albums. read less
Comments

Carnatic (Vocal & Violin) Expert

We can't say that much sure that we do not follow time theory but in concerts we start with suitable raagas for the evening or morning schedules. In Temple, the oduvars are still following the pann murai based on the time theory only. It is still existing only.
Comments

"Unleash The Musician In You" - Blue Soul School Of Music

Not really, by understanding theory, it will only broaden the horizon of creativity.
Comments

Music is divine

if we do simultaneously that would be the best
Comments

Hindustani classical vocalist

My answer is a personal reflection of my understanding and study of Hindustani music. I believe ragas can be sung at any time, I have practised Multani and Yaman in the morning, and air bhairav and Bibhas in the evening. I don't believe it distorted my presentation of the raga... Or the time of the day...
read more
My answer is a personal reflection of my understanding and study of Hindustani music. I believe ragas can be sung at any time, I have practised Multani and Yaman in the morning, and air bhairav and Bibhas in the evening. I don't believe it distorted my presentation of the raga... Or the time of the day affected my singing. Having said so, when ragas were alloted to a particular prahar of the day by our learned gurus, there was a science to it. But finally music is subjective and persons! read less
Comments

View 7 more Answers

Related Questions

What are the types of vocal music?
There are many forms of music. Indian music itself has many genres. The most popular being Carnatic and Hindusthani.
Sagar
0 0
5
Is carnatic music easy?
Carnatic music is not inherently easy, as it requires mastering intricate ragas, talas, and gamakas. However, with structured learning, dedication, and regular practice, it becomes more approachable over time.
Trupti
0 0
5
Why is Carnatic Music not as famous as Hindustani Music?
Carnatic music's smaller audience and perceived niche status, coupled with its more structured and vocal-centric nature.
Vishal
0 0
6
Is there any age limit to learn and become a professional singer?
No age limit, Your dedication matters.
Debidutta
looking for a teacher
Search urbonprow website.
Kavya

Now ask question in any of the 1000+ Categories, and get Answers from Tutors and Trainers on UrbanPro.com

Ask a Question

Related Lessons


Hindustani Classical Music.
Hindustani classical music has strongly influenced Indonesian Culture. Especially, popular music, mostly in instrumentation, melody etc. Classical music can be divided into melody and rhythm; there is...

Basic Breathing Exercises for better Singing, Tip-6
Do it Excercise : Sit on the floor feet tucked under you, stretch out your arms and upper body. Notice how low and expandedyour breath is in this “child’s pose” yoga position. Only...
V

Vinod Kumar

3 0
0

dear learner please have a some paishance to be a good musician.
now a days i am frequently getting a question, to the most of my students and visitors.(how much time it will take to be a good musician?). i am clueless, but will request you all don't ever put much...

Basic Breathing Exercises for better Singing, Tip-10
Do it Excercise : Same as previous exercise #7 with a sustained “zz” sound. Try to make the zz sound with no feeling of tightness in your throat.Can you sustain this as long as you did the...

Looking for Indian Classical Music Classes ?

Learn from the Best Tutors on UrbanPro

Are you a Tutor or Training Institute?

Join UrbanPro Today to find students near you