Find the best tutors and institutes for Class 12 Tuition
Q6:
Compare and contrast the advantages and disadvantages of production of genetically modified crops.
Solution :
1. Conceptual Framework of Genetically Modified (GM) Crops
Genetically Modified (GM) crops are plants in which the genetic material (DNA) has been altered in a way that does not occur naturally by mating and/or natural recombination. This is achieved through recombinant DNA technology, enabling the introduction of specific desirable traits [Per the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety].
2. Comparative Analysis of GM Crop Production
The following table illustrates the multifaceted impact of GM technology in modern agriculture.
| Aspect | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Agricultural Yield | Increased yields due to enhanced resistance to pests and abiotic stresses [Biotechnological optimization]. | Potential for "genetic pollution" or gene flow to wild relatives, altering ecosystems. |
| Pesticide Use | Reduction in the chemical application of insecticides, as seen in Bt crops expressing cry toxins [Cry protein mechanism]. | Evolution of "super-pests" due to continuous selective pressure on target insect populations. |
| Nutritional Value | Biofortification (e.g., Golden Rice, enriched with Vitamin A precursors). | Risk of introducing new allergens or toxins into the food supply for human consumption. |
| Sustainability | Improved efficiency in mineral usage and tolerance to harsh climatic conditions. | Economic dependence on large corporations for proprietary seeds and patented genetic traits. |
3. Visual Representation of Gene Transfer Mechanism
4. Detailed Evaluation of Trade-offs
A. Strategic Advantages (The Pro-Biotech Argument)
- Stress Tolerance: Crops are engineered to withstand abiotic stresses such as cold, drought, salt, and heat, which are exacerbated by climate change [Environmental resilience].
- Reduction in Post-Harvest Losses: Modifications to plant metabolism can delay senescence and ripening, reducing food waste [Biochemical regulation].
- Enhanced Nutrient Uptake: Efficiency of nitrogen and phosphorus uptake is improved, reducing the ecological footprint of synthetic fertilizer application [Ecosystem conservation].
B. Strategic Disadvantages (The Ethical & Safety Argument)
- Unintended Effects: Insertional mutagenesis may result in pleiotropic effects, where the expression of other genes is inadvertently altered [Genomic instability].
- Biodiversity Concerns: Use of herbicide-tolerant crops may increase the usage of specific herbicides (e.g., glyphosate), affecting non-target biodiversity like pollinators [Trophic level impact].
- Socio-economic Barriers: Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) associated with transgenic seeds create a dependency cycle for farmers, potentially threatening food sovereignty [Ethical/Legal framework].
Final Solution: The production of Genetically Modified crops offers a transformative potential to ensure global food security through enhanced productivity and nutritional quality. However, these advancements must be balanced against critical considerations of environmental biosafety, the development of resistant pest populations, and complex socio-economic implications, necessitating stringent regulatory oversight and comprehensive risk assessment protocols.
More Questions from Class 12 Biology Biotechnology and Its Applications EXERCISES
- Q1: Which part of the plant is best suited for making virus-free plants and why?
- Q1: Which part of the plant is best suited for making virus-free plants and why?
- Q2: What is the major advantage of producing plants by micropropagation?
- Q2: What is the major advantage of producing plants by micropropagation?
- Q3: Find out what the various components of the medium used for propagation of an explant in vitro are?
- Q3: Find out what the various components of the medium used for propagation of an explant in vitro are?
- Q4: Crystals of Bt toxin produced by some bacteria do not kill the bacteria themselves because –
- Q4: Crystals of Bt toxin produced by some bacteria do not kill the bacteria themselves because –
- Q5: What are transgenic bacteria? Illustrate using any one example.
- Q5: What are transgenic bacteria? Illustrate using any one example.
- Q6: Compare and contrast the advantages and disadvantages of production of genetically modified crops.
- Q7: What are Cry proteins? Name an organism that produce it. How has man exploited this protein to his benefit?
- Q7: What are Cry proteins? Name an organism that produce it. How has man exploited this protein to his benefit?
- Q8: What is gene therapy? Illustrate using the example of adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency.
- Q8: What is gene therapy? Illustrate using the example of adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency.
- Q9: Digrammatically represent the experimental steps in cloning and expressing an human gene (say the gene for growth hormone) into a bacterium like E. coli ?
- Q9: Digrammatically represent the experimental steps in cloning and expressing an human gene (say the gene for growth hormone) into a bacterium like E. coli ?
- Q10: Can you suggest a method to remove oil (hydrocarbon) from seeds based on your understanding of rDNA technology and chemistry of oil?
- Q10: Can you suggest a method to remove oil (hydrocarbon) from seeds based on your understanding of rDNA technology and chemistry of oil?
- Q11: Find out from internet what is golden rice.
- Q11: Find out from internet what is golden rice.
- Q12: Does our blood have proteases and nucleases?
- Q12: Does our blood have proteases and nucleases?
- Q13: Consult internet and find out how to make orally active protein pharmaceutical. What is the major problem to be encountered?
- Q13: Consult internet and find out how to make orally active protein pharmaceutical. What is the major problem to be encountered?
CBSE Solutions for Class 12 Biology Biotechnology and Its Applications
Chapters in CBSE - Class 12 Biology
- Reproduction in Organisms
- Human Reproduction
- Reproductive Health
- Principles of Inheritance and Variation
- Molecular Basis of Inheritance
- Evolution
- Human Health and Disease
- Strategies for Enhancement in Food Production
- Microbes in Human Welfare
- Biotechnology: Principles and Processes
- Organisms and Populations
- Ecosystem
- Biodiversity and Conservation
- Environmental Issues
Top Tutors who teach Biotechnology and Its Applications
Have been teaching maths cbse since last 35 years and still favourite among my students.
They teach you very well. Let's clarify each and every concept. Let's take a regular test. Chapter-wise assignments are provided. They give extra time.
I have completed MPhil in Physics and teaching in college for 6 years. I am giving online/ home tuition since 2015. I prefer mathematics .
I hold master degree in physics , I have 9 years teaching experience in college . I can teach each and every topic very easily and make it strong for the students. I can get your child very good score in their exams. I am a reputed tutor with track record of qualifying your child for cet, neet and jee.
He explains very well and helps to get topics easily. Supportive to me in my studies and helps to clear all my doubts. A very good teacher.
- Helping the student gain confidence in him/herself and with respect to the subject - Thorough preparation with help of model and previous years' question papers - Understanding the student's learning style and adapting my teaching accordingly - Making lessons interesting by using different methods of teaching (Sharing YouTube links and relevant weblinks)
Her dedication to her students extends beyond the classroom, creating a lasting impact.one of the best teacher I have ever met ,In essence, she is not just a teacher but a mentor who inspires and shapes the minds and character of her students.
My experience of teaching is great. I teach with great enthusiasm and we will make this teaching learning process easy and interesting together.
Way of teaching simply I liked. I understood everything. I have started understanding numerical too.
Other Subjects in CBSE - Class 12
Download free CBSE - Class 12 Biology Biotechnology and Its Applications EXERCISES worksheets
Download Now