Find the best tutors and institutes for Class 12 Tuition
Q6:
Compare and contrast the advantages and disadvantages of production of genetically modified crops.
Solution :
Theoretical Foundation: Genetically Modified (GM) Crops
Genetically Modified (GM) crops are agricultural plants whose genomes have been specifically altered using recombinant DNA (rDNA) technology. By inserting a specific gene of interest (transgene) from a distinct organism—whether bacterial, viral, or another plant—scientists can confer novel phenotypic traits that do not naturally occur in the species. While this molecular engineering offers unprecedented agricultural optimization, it simultaneously introduces complex ecological, physiological, and socio-economic variables.
Visualizing the Dichotomy of GM Crop Production
The following schematic illustrates the localized and systemic impacts of deploying transgenic plants in an agricultural ecosystem, mapping the vectors of both advantages and disadvantages.
Step 1: Analytical Breakdown of Advantages
The engineering of GM crops offers solutions to long-standing agronomic and nutritional challenges through precise molecular alterations:
- Enhanced Crop Yields and Pest Resistance: Transgenic crops significantly reduce crop losses by conferring inherent resistance to pathogens and insects.
[Justification: The incorporation of specific $cry$ genes (e.g., $cry1Ac$, $cry2Ab$) from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis into crops like cotton and maize results in the expression of endotoxins. These endotoxins undergo proteolytic cleavage in the alkaline gut flora of target Lepidopteran insects, creating pores in the midgut epithelial cells, leading to insect death and reducing reliance on chemical pesticides.] - Tolerance to Abiotic Stresses: Genes can be introduced to enhance survival under adverse environmental conditions (cold, drought, soil salinity, and heat).
[Justification: Introduction of osmo-protectant genes enables the plant to maintain cellular turgor and metabolic function despite unfavorable external water potentials.] - Nutritional Biofortification: rDNA technology is utilized to increase the concentration of vitamins, minerals, and essential amino acids in staple crops.
[Example: "Golden Rice" is genetically modified with two genes—$psy$ (phytoene synthase) from daffodil and $crtI$ (phytoene desaturase) from the soil bacterium Erwinia uredovora—allowing the endosperm to synthesize $\beta$-carotene, a precursor to Vitamin A. This mitigates Vitamin A deficiency in populations reliant on rice.] - Reduction in Post-Harvest Losses: Genetic modifications can alter the metabolic pathways that govern fruit ripening, extending shelf life and reducing waste during transport.
[Example: The Flavr Savr tomato utilizes antisense RNA technology to silence the gene encoding the enzyme polygalacturonase, preventing the rapid degradation of pectin in the cell wall and delaying fruit softening.]
Step 2: Analytical Breakdown of Disadvantages
Despite their agronomic benefits, GM crops introduce systemic risks to ecosystems, human biology, and the socio-economic structure of agriculture:
- Ecological Risks (Transgene Escape & Superweeds): There is a severe risk of horizontal gene transfer or cross-pollination between GM crops and their wild, weedy relatives.
[Ecological Consequence: The transfer of herbicide-resistance genes to wild relatives can lead to the emergence of "superweeds," disrupting natural ecosystem equilibria and necessitating harsher chemical control.] - Adverse Effects on Non-Target Organisms: The generalized expression of insecticidal proteins may inadvertently harm beneficial insects.
[Justification: Pollinators (such as bees) and detritivores, which are essential for nutrient cycling and agricultural fecundity, may ingest toxins from transgenic pollen or plant detritus, leading to declines in biodiversity.] - Potential Human Health Hazards: The introduction of foreign genes introduces novel proteins into the human diet.
[Physiological Mechanism: These novel proteins may act as potent antigens, triggering allergic reactions (Type I hypersensitivity). Furthermore, the use of antibiotic resistance genes as selectable markers during the GM production process raises concerns about the potential transfer of these resistance traits to pathogenic bacteria in the human gut microbiome.] - Socio-Economic & Ethical Implications (Seed Monopolies): GM seed technology is often governed by strict intellectual property rights and patents held by large biotechnology corporations.
[Socio-Economic Impact: Practices like "Terminator Technology" (genetic use restriction technology) engineer seeds to produce sterile offspring, legally and biologically forcing farmers in developing nations to purchase expensive new seeds every planting season, thereby compromising food sovereignty.]
Step 3: Comparative Matrix
| Domain of Impact | Advantages of GM Crops | Disadvantages of GM Crops |
|---|---|---|
| Agricultural Economics | Higher yields per hectare; drastic reduction in the cost and labor associated with applying chemical pesticides. | High initial cost of patented seeds; prohibition on the traditional practice of seed-saving for subsequent seasons. |
| Environmental Impact | Lower accumulation of toxic agricultural chemicals (pesticides/herbicides) in the soil and local water tables. | Threat of outcrossing resulting in "superweeds"; potential toxicity to non-target insect species and broader biodiversity loss. |
| Human Health | Biofortified crops eradicate specific dietary deficiencies (e.g., Vitamin A deficiency, iron deficiency). | Expression of novel proteins can elicit unpredictable allergenic responses; risk of antibiotic resistance gene transfer. |
| Plant Physiology | Enhanced resilience to extreme osmotic/abiotic stress and delayed senescence (longer shelf life). | Potential metabolic trade-offs within the plant where the continuous expression of foreign genes limits energy available for general growth. |
Final Solution: The production of genetically modified crops represents a powerful double-edged sword in biotechnology. The principal advantages lie in agronomic optimization (pest resistance via $cry$ genes, stress tolerance) and nutritional biofortification (e.g., $\beta$-carotene in Golden Rice). Conversely, the fundamental disadvantages are rooted in ecological disruption (transgene escape leading to superweeds, harm to non-target pollinators), human health uncertainties (allergenicity), and severe socio-economic inequities driven by corporate seed monopolies. Comprehensive regulatory oversight and biosafety assessments are strictly required to balance these vectors.
More Questions from Class 12 Biology Biotechnology and Its Applications EXERCISES
- Q1: Which part of the plant is best suited for making virus-free plants and why?
- Q1: Which part of the plant is best suited for making virus-free plants and why?
- Q2: What is the major advantage of producing plants by micropropagation?
- Q2: What is the major advantage of producing plants by micropropagation?
- Q3: Find out what the various components of the medium used for propagation of an explant in vitro are?
- Q3: Find out what the various components of the medium used for propagation of an explant in vitro are?
- Q4: Crystals of Bt toxin produced by some bacteria do not kill the bacteria themselves because –
- Q4: Crystals of Bt toxin produced by some bacteria do not kill the bacteria themselves because –
- Q5: What are transgenic bacteria? Illustrate using any one example.
- Q5: What are transgenic bacteria? Illustrate using any one example.
- Q6: Compare and contrast the advantages and disadvantages of production of genetically modified crops.
- Q7: What are Cry proteins? Name an organism that produce it. How has man exploited this protein to his benefit?
- Q7: What are Cry proteins? Name an organism that produce it. How has man exploited this protein to his benefit?
- Q8: What is gene therapy? Illustrate using the example of adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency.
- Q8: What is gene therapy? Illustrate using the example of adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency.
- Q9: Digrammatically represent the experimental steps in cloning and expressing an human gene (say the gene for growth hormone) into a bacterium like E. coli ?
- Q9: Digrammatically represent the experimental steps in cloning and expressing an human gene (say the gene for growth hormone) into a bacterium like E. coli ?
- Q10: Can you suggest a method to remove oil (hydrocarbon) from seeds based on your understanding of rDNA technology and chemistry of oil?
- Q10: Can you suggest a method to remove oil (hydrocarbon) from seeds based on your understanding of rDNA technology and chemistry of oil?
- Q11: Find out from internet what is golden rice.
- Q11: Find out from internet what is golden rice.
- Q12: Does our blood have proteases and nucleases?
- Q12: Does our blood have proteases and nucleases?
- Q13: Consult internet and find out how to make orally active protein pharmaceutical. What is the major problem to be encountered?
- Q13: Consult internet and find out how to make orally active protein pharmaceutical. What is the major problem to be encountered?
CBSE Solutions for Class 12 Biology Biotechnology and Its Applications
Chapters in CBSE - Class 12 Biology
- Reproduction in Organisms
- Human Reproduction
- Reproductive Health
- Principles of Inheritance and Variation
- Molecular Basis of Inheritance
- Evolution
- Human Health and Disease
- Strategies for Enhancement in Food Production
- Microbes in Human Welfare
- Biotechnology: Principles and Processes
- Organisms and Populations
- Ecosystem
- Biodiversity and Conservation
- Environmental Issues
Top Tutors who teach Biotechnology and Its Applications
Have been teaching maths cbse since last 35 years and still favourite among my students.
They teach you very well. Let's clarify each and every concept. Let's take a regular test. Chapter-wise assignments are provided. They give extra time.
I have completed MPhil in Physics and teaching in college for 6 years. I am giving online/ home tuition since 2015. I prefer mathematics .
I hold master degree in physics , I have 9 years teaching experience in college . I can teach each and every topic very easily and make it strong for the students. I can get your child very good score in their exams. I am a reputed tutor with track record of qualifying your child for cet, neet and jee.
He explains very well and helps to get topics easily. Supportive to me in my studies and helps to clear all my doubts. A very good teacher.
- Helping the student gain confidence in him/herself and with respect to the subject - Thorough preparation with help of model and previous years' question papers - Understanding the student's learning style and adapting my teaching accordingly - Making lessons interesting by using different methods of teaching (Sharing YouTube links and relevant weblinks)
Her dedication to her students extends beyond the classroom, creating a lasting impact.one of the best teacher I have ever met ,In essence, she is not just a teacher but a mentor who inspires and shapes the minds and character of her students.
My experience of teaching is great. I teach with great enthusiasm and we will make this teaching learning process easy and interesting together.
Way of teaching simply I liked. I understood everything. I have started understanding numerical too.
Other Subjects in CBSE - Class 12
Download free CBSE - Class 12 Biology Biotechnology and Its Applications EXERCISES worksheets
Download Now