Find the best tutors and institutes for Class 11 Tuition
Q2.25:
A man walking briskly in rain with speed (v) must slant his umbrella forward making an angle (\theta) with the vertical. A student derives the following relation between (\theta) and (v) : (\tan \theta = v) and checks that the relation has a correct limit: as (v \rightarrow 0), (\theta \rightarrow 0), as expected. (We are assuming there is no strong wind and that the rain falls vertically for a stationary man). Do you think this relation can be correct ? If not, guess the correct relation.
Solution :
Step 1: Dimensional Analysis of the Proposed Relation
The student proposes the relation: $\tan \theta = v$.
To evaluate the validity of this equation, we must perform a dimensional analysis on both sides of the equation [Per the Principle of Homogeneity of Dimensions].
- Left-Hand Side (LHS): The term $\tan \theta$ represents a trigonometric function of an angle. Since an angle is the ratio of arc length to radius ($s/r$), it is a dimensionless quantity ($[M^0 L^0 T^0]$). Therefore, $\tan \theta$ is dimensionless.
- Right-Hand Side (RHS): The variable $v$ represents the speed of the man, which has dimensions of distance per unit time ($[L T^{-1}]$).
Comparing the two: $[M^0 L^0 T^0] \neq [L T^{-1}]$. Since the dimensions do not match, the relation $\tan \theta = v$ is physically incorrect, despite satisfying the boundary condition as $v \to 0$.
Step 2: Deriving the Correct Physical Relation
Let $v_r$ be the velocity of the rain falling vertically relative to the ground, and $v_m$ be the velocity of the man walking horizontally. To stay dry, the man must point his umbrella in the direction of the relative velocity of the rain with respect to himself ($\vec{v}_{rm}$).
$\vec{v}_{rm} = \vec{v}_r - \vec{v}_m$
Vectorially, if $\vec{v}_r$ is directed downward and $\vec{v}_m$ is directed forward, the resultant vector $\vec{v}_{rm}$ makes an angle $\theta$ with the vertical. From the geometry of the velocity vector triangle:
Using trigonometry in the right-angled triangle formed by these vectors [By Trigonometric Ratios in Right Triangles]:
$\tan \theta = \frac{\text{Opposite}}{\text{Adjacent}} = \frac{v_m}{v_r}$
Step 3: Justification and Verification
The correct relation is $\tan \theta = \frac{v}{v_r}$, where $v_r$ is the constant speed of the falling rain.
| Condition | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Dimensionality | $\frac{[L T^{-1}]}{[L T^{-1}]} = [M^0 L^0 T^0]$. The equation is now dimensionally consistent. |
| Limit: $v \to 0$ | $\tan \theta \to 0 \implies \theta \to 0$. The condition holds. |
| Limit: $v \to \infty$ | $\tan \theta \to \infty \implies \theta \to 90^\circ$. The umbrella must be held horizontally for very high speeds. |
Final Solution: The relation $\tan \theta = v$ is incorrect because it is not dimensionally consistent. The correct relation is $\tan \theta = \frac{v}{v_r}$, where $v_r$ is the constant speed at which the rain falls.
More Questions from Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements Additional Exercises
- Q2.25: A man walking briskly in rain with speed $v$ must slant his umbrella forward making an angle $\theta$ with the vertical. A student derives the following relation between $\theta$ and $v$ : $\tan \theta = v$ and checks that the relation has a correct limit: as $v \to 0$, $\theta \to 0$, as expected. (We are assuming there is no strong wind and that the rain falls vertically for a stationary man). Do you think this relation can be correct ? If not, guess the correct relation.
- Q2.26: It is claimed that two cesium clocks, if allowed to run for 100 years, free from any disturbance, may differ by only about 0.02 s. What does this imply for the accuracy of the standard cesium clock in measuring a time-interval of 1 s ?
- Q2.26: It is claimed that two cesium clocks, if allowed to run for 100 years, free from any disturbance, may differ by only about 0.02 s. What does this imply for the accuracy of the standard cesium clock in measuring a time-interval of 1 s ?
- Q2.27: Estimate the average mass density of a sodium atom assuming its size to be about 2.5 Å. (Use the known values of Avogadro’s number and the atomic mass of sodium). Compare it with the mass density of sodium in its crystalline phase : 970 kg m$^{–3}$. Are the two densities of the same order of magnitude ? If so, why ?
- Q2.27: Estimate the average mass density of a sodium atom assuming its size to be about 2.5 (Å). (Use the known values of Avogadro’s number and the atomic mass of sodium). Compare it with the mass density of sodium in its crystalline phase : 970 (kg m^{-3}). Are the two densities of the same order of magnitude ? If so, why ?
- Q2.28: The unit of length convenient on the nuclear scale is a fermi : 1 f = $10^{–15}$ m. Nuclear sizes obey roughly the following empirical relation : $r = r_0 A^{1/3}$ where $r$ is the radius of the nucleus, $A$ its mass number, and $r_o$ is a constant equal to about, 1.2 f. Show that the rule implies that nuclear mass density is nearly constant for different nuclei. Estimate the mass density of sodium nucleus. Compare it with the average mass density of a sodium atom obtained in Exercise. 2.27.
- Q2.28: The unit of length convenient on the nuclear scale is a fermi : (1 f = 10^{-15} m). Nuclear sizes obey roughly the following empirical relation : (r = r_{0} A^{1/3}) where (r) is the radius of the nucleus, (A) its mass number, and (r_{o}) is a constant equal to about, 1.2 f. Show that the rule implies that nuclear mass density is nearly constant for different nuclei. Estimate the mass density of sodium nucleus. Compare it with the average mass density of a sodium atom obtained in Exercise. 2.27.
- Q2.29: A LASER is a source of very intense, monochromatic, and unidirectional beam of light. These properties of a laser light can be exploited to measure long distances. The distance of the Moon from the Earth has been already determined very precisely using a laser as a source of light. A laser light beamed at the Moon takes 2.56 s to return after reflection at the Moon’s surface. How much is the radius of the lunar orbit around the Earth ?
- Q2.29: A LASER is a source of very intense, monochromatic, and unidirectional beam of light. These properties of a laser light can be exploited to measure long distances. The distance of the Moon from the Earth has been already determined very precisely using a laser as a source of light. A laser light beamed at the Moon takes 2.56 s to return after reflection at the Moon’s surface. How much is the radius of the lunar orbit around the Earth ?
- Q2.30: A SONAR (sound navigation and ranging) uses ultrasonic waves to detect and locate objects under water. In a submarine equipped with a SONAR, the time delay between generation of a probe wave and the reception of its echo after reflection from an enemy submarine is found to be 77.0 s. What is the distance of the enemy submarine? (Speed of sound in water = 1450 m s$^{–1}$).
- Q2.30: A SONAR (sound navigation and ranging) uses ultrasonic waves to detect and locate objects under water. In a submarine equipped with a SONAR, the time delay between generation of a probe wave and the reception of its echo after reflection from an enemy submarine is found to be 77.0 s. What is the distance of the enemy submarine? (Speed of sound in water = 1450 (m s^{-1})).
- Q2.31: The farthest objects in our Universe discovered by modern astronomers are so distant that light emitted by them takes billions of years to reach the Earth. These objects (known as quasars) have many puzzling features, which have not yet been satisfactorily explained. What is the distance in km of a quasar from which light takes 3.0 billion years to reach us ?
- Q2.31: The farthest objects in our Universe discovered by modern astronomers are so distant that light emitted by them takes billions of years to reach the Earth. These objects (known as quasars) have many puzzling features, which have not yet been satisfactorily explained. What is the distance in km of a quasar from which light takes 3.0 billion years to reach us ?
- Q2.32: It is a well known fact that during a total solar eclipse the disk of the moon almost completely covers the disk of the Sun. From this fact and from the information you can gather from examples 2.3 and 2.4, determine the approximate diameter of the moon.
- Q2.32: It is a well known fact that during a total solar eclipse the disk of the moon almost completely covers the disk of the Sun. From this fact and from the information you can gather from examples 2.3 and 2.4, determine the approximate diameter of the moon.
- Q2.33: A great physicist of this century (P.A.M. Dirac) loved playing with numerical values of Fundamental constants of nature. This led him to an interesting observation. Dirac found that from the basic constants of atomic physics ($c$, $e$, mass of electron, mass of proton) and the gravitational constant $G$, he could arrive at a number with the dimension of time. Further, it was a very large number, its magnitude being close to the present estimate on the age of the universe ($\sim$15 billion years). From the table of fundamental constants in this book, try to see if you too can construct this number (or any other interesting number you can think of ). If its coincidence with the age of the universe were significant, what would this imply for the constancy of fundamental constants?
- Q2.33: A great physicist of this century (P.A.M. Dirac) loved playing with numerical values of Fundamental constants of nature. This led him to an interesting observation. Dirac found that from the basic constants of atomic physics ((c), (e), mass of electron, mass of proton) and the gravitational constant (G), he could arrive at a number with the dimension of time. Further, it was a very large number, its magnitude being close to the present estimate on the age of the universe (~15 billion years). From the table of fundamental constants in this book, try to see if you too can construct this number (or any other interesting number you can think of ). If its coincidence with the age of the universe were significant, what would this imply for the constancy of fundamental constants?
CBSE Solutions for Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements
Chapters in CBSE - Class 11 Physics
Top Tutors who teach Units and Measurements
Top Tutor
Indiranagar, Bangalore
20 yrs of
Exp
10 students
884 hrs of classes completed
1000
per hour
Online Classes
Student's Home
Tutor's home
Prof. Of physics, ex-faculty of fiitjee & aakash, 20 yrs exp. Taught more than 1 lakh jee/neet aspirants, out of which more than 10, 000 students have been selected in iit and best medical colleges. I am the expert for iit-jee, neet, cbse, ib, igcse, as/a level, mcat. I work at the student's grasping level and you can understand it so easily regardless of prior knowledge. You can score 100% in your cbse board exam. I can help jee/neet students with all type of assignment from any institute like fiitjee, allen, sri chaitanya, narayna, akash, resonance. Feel the next level of physics by solving hc verma, cengage, dc pandey, ie irodov with me in so simple and advanced way. Learn tricks and techniques to solve quickly. Save my kids' precious time by making quick decision.
Very good knowledge of the subject. Adjusts to the pace of the student and provides ample information according to the requirement of the student.
Super Tutor
Prem Nagar, Hisar
20 yrs of
Exp
49 students
10127 hrs of classes completed
600
per hour
Online Classes
Student's Home
I am very expert in teaching the basics with simple examples and make to understand the concepts very simple way. It will helpful for the students to understand and apply at a given situation especially application-based and high thinking problems. In fact, I will not teach the student but help to learn the subject in a more independent way and comfort.
I really loved Sir's way of clearing the concepts and not just teaching for the sake of doing so. Any student who wishes to clear concepts deeply should approach him.
Top Tutor
HSR Layout 1st Sector, Bangalore
11 yrs of
Exp
5 students
2027 hrs of classes completed
400
per hour
Online Classes
Student's Home
I am a B.TECH. graduate from computer science.I am completely dedicated in teaching .I have experience of 10 years in teaching field. In that 10 years, I have taught 180 students(1 on 1)as a tutor.I have experience of teaching all types of boards like (CBSE,ICSE,IGCSE, ISC,STATE BOARD,IB) .My specialisation is in mathematics subject.I teach mathematics from 7th grade to 12th grade.I keep patience while teaching to the students,I try my best to clear the concepts regarding that chapter either in maths.Student can ask their doubts many times until their concepts is not clear.I have given good results to the students and also generated confidence in them specially in mathematics. I am the best for teaching maths subject. I first try to understand the student ( weakness and strength) and then I plan how to make any student best in math. I teach with full dedication and create interest for maths subject in my students. Thanks.
Prakhar Sir’s teaching was very good and have got clear conceptual understanding on the topics covered.
Top Tutor
Kadiramangalam, Tiruvidamarudur
2 yrs of
Exp
6 students
180 hrs of classes completed
450
per hour
Online Classes
Working in an ICSE school and also Qualified Physics tutor (CTET, TNTET, PG TRB) teaching CBSE & ICSE students with clear explanations, interactive methods, and focused support to improve concepts, confidence, and results. I have helped nearly 30 plus students to overcome the fear of subjects especially physics.
Super Tutor
H C Sarani, Kolkata
18 yrs of
Exp
9 students
2071 hrs of classes completed
500
per hour
Online Classes
Tutor's home
Students of 11th standard faces major challenges in three segments: 1) Boolean Algebra & Logic Gates 2) Developing the programming logic and 3) Database Management System 4) Java/ Python
I am very thankful to sir for making all the conceps clear and taught in a very fruitful way. Thank you so much sir. Highly satisfied.
Other Subjects in CBSE - Class 11
Download free CBSE - Class 11 Physics Units and Measurements Additional Exercises worksheets
Download Now
